pull down to refresh

The only thing I know about Rainer Zitelmann is what I learned about his work while translating his 2023 book In Defense of Capitalism: Debunking the Myths (to Swedish: Myter om kapitalism).
It wasn't the greatest read of my life, but Zitelmann is a prolific writer with an incredible chip on his shoulder, so he won't stop working and won't stop producing material—largely, though, in the German-speaking world.
He apparently has a new book out (shocker...) called The Origins of Poverty and Wealth —and he does what any self-respecting intellectual does when that's the case: Write something for the Wall Street Journal!
So here he is, writing about the very lovely and (lovable!) character Ayn Rand, the "high priestess of reason"
In contrast to the economists and political philosophers she admired, she wrote novel. And novels, she thought, were "the most compelling kind of propaganda":
Still: this, as Zitelmann writes in the Opinion piece, is damn right:

"The historical evidence supporting capitalism is so convincing that it’s difficult to understand why some people view it so negatively"

...and he says that
Modern criticism of capitalism persists because emotions rather than facts and figures tend to sway public opinion.
Not sure that's the entire reason, but sure: ignorance + malice explains a LOT.
Whatcha think, Stackers?

non-paywalled here: https://archive.md/LiuCg
I think people mostly do like what capitalism is, but they dislike what they think capitalism is.
reply
Not enough faith in self interest and the invisible hand of Adam Smith
reply
That's true too
reply
Libertarians forget how Adam Smith warned of the inherent tendency of merchants to collude in order the swing the market in their favour. Free markets are an illusion- regulation is essential to prevent merchants from rigging markets. The best example of this is in modern day empire USA where now the biggest merchants own the government via patronage - compared to CCP China where the government strictly regulates markets to prevent rent seeking. Chinas economy is growing and coming to dominate the world while USA declines under its crony capitalism. China exhibits a more functional example of capitalism by regulating capital while capital in the empire USA now owns and controls the government. The most powerful and productive capitalism requires some government involvement and restriction of market rigging by major companies and power projection to enhance its economy, markets and resource hegemony. China is building its Belt and Road empire of global infrastructure while the US empire crumbles under crony capitalism, tariffs and rigged rentseeking monopolist markets.
reply
That the only real, free market is called the black market these days is all you need to know...
reply
37 sats \ 1 reply \ @kepford 21h
I get what he's saying but Rand did a pretty amazing job of influencing thought IMO. The number of companies named after things in her books and successful people that credit her book is huge. Not to mention how many books she sold.
Humans are moved more by art than reason. Humans are seldom rational either. Rand's writings are filled with both reason and rationality. Even with all of her success you never hear her name mentioned when theres a list of influential women. It's very telling.
She had plenty of flaws and I think some of her biggest are related to emotion and likely due to trauma she suffered.
reply
Years ago I worked with a woman named Dagny. No question her parents read Rand.
reply
This capitalism, was that before or after 1913?
And will it return as a free market anytime soon as Bitcoin scales?
reply
Unclear on both accounts
reply
Yup, but its a sure thing that we all have to work hard on the latter!
reply
20 sats \ 1 reply \ @k00b 20h
I came to appreciate capitalism through Rand but had trouble with this very thing. She asked readers to be independent, stoic, and thinking yet romantic, spontaneous, and reverent. I ended up squaring the circle by admitting she was exaggerating for effect. I'm happy to learn she admitted it somewhere.
reply
175 sats \ 0 replies \ @Artilektt 4h
I mean she was a woman after all. Jk JK
reply
38 sats \ 4 replies \ @Satosora 22h
I remember when I was reading Atlas Shrugged on a plane, an older gentleman was kind enough to tell me that this is not how the world works. Bitcoin will change that.
reply
Did he elaborate?
Did he say the world runs on 5 year plans?
reply
9 sats \ 1 reply \ @Satosora 20h
The older gentleman didnt elaborate. He just pointed it out to me.
reply
Economic growth depends upon the ability of governments to exert and project power. In this way they capture and control resources and markets. It is in this way that powerful empires emerge. US wealth today is largely based upon its military power and its domination and control of the global banking monetary system and the major global regulatory institutions and protocols- eg SWIFT, IMF, World Bank, BIS. Without a government in sync with its merchants and exerting its power projection in their favour there has never been a powerful and wealthy empire. Libertarians ignore this reality.
reply
I've found a lot of people have an opinion on it who've never read it
reply
Malice is based on emotion?
reply