pull down to refresh

Inspired by Kevin Kelly’s classic blog post "You Are Not Late".
The frontier is still wide open.
The most common lament about bitcoin today is that you're too late. That all the opportunities were over a decade ago, when bitcoin could be successfully mined on laptops or bought for pennies. That the pioneers already staked their claims, built their fortunes, and locked up all the value. I want to convince you that this perspective is completely wrong.
In fact, we are still living in year zero of a monetary revolution. What appears to be a mature, 15-year-old technology is actually embryonic. What looks like a settled landscape is really just a foundation. The real rush to transform our global economy with an open monetary system hasn't really started yet. Yes, you missed mining bitcoin on your laptop. You missed buying it for a dollar. But you haven't missed the crucial part: building the future of money. It’s civilizational-scale transformation. Consider this: Less than 1% of the world's population has ever used bitcoin. Most of those who own it treat it as a speculation, not as money. The infrastructure for using it as an everyday currency is still primitive. Lightning Network adoption is in its infancy. Most people still can't explain what makes bitcoin valuable or how it works.
It may look like we're late if you judge bitcoin's timeline against internet companies. But bitcoin isn't a company - it's a new form of money. And money's timelines are measured in decades and centuries, not years. We're not in bitcoin's equivalent of the dot-com boom. We're in the early hacker phase of the internet where we’re using a combination of BBSes; siloed internet service providers; and Gopher protocol to just barely interconnect across these walled gardens of information.
The opportunities ahead are actually far larger than those behind us. Here's why:
  1. Every financial instrument, contract, and transaction in the world will eventually interface with bitcoin in some way. The market for these financial tools is orders of magnitude larger than bitcoin's current market cap.
  2. We haven't even started building most of the critical infrastructure. The equivalent of web browsers and social networks for bitcoin are still waiting to be invented.
  3. The real adoption curve begins when bitcoin becomes invisible - when people use it without even thinking about using it, just like they use TCP/IP today without knowing it.
  4. The hard problems - scaling, privacy, smart contracts on bitcoin - are still largely unsolved.
  5. We haven't even begun to imagine most of bitcoin's uses. Just as the internet became far more than just email, bitcoin will become far more than just digital gold or payments.
The early adopters didn't grab all the opportunities - they just grabbed the obvious ones. They bought and held bitcoin. They built exchanges. They created wallets. But that's like saying the early internet pioneers grabbed all the opportunities by building email services.
But, but…here is the thing. In terms of bitcoin, nothing has happened yet. Sure, there are still real opportunities in speculation today, but we’re far enough along that you can actually build useful open source software and commercial tools to help people. Consider working on the following:
  • Create financial tools that make bitcoin more useful to more people
  • Build the interfaces that make it invisible
  • Develop the applications and networks that couldn’t be built before the internet had its own native digital currency
Because here is the thing the greybeard cypherpunks in 2050 will tell you: Can you imagine how awesome it would have been to be an entrepreneur in 2024? It was a wide-open frontier! You could pick almost any category and connect AIs to their own money and rip open new frontiers. Few people had even joined Nostr yet! Expectations and barriers were low. It was easy to be the first. And then they would sigh, “Oh, if only we realized how possible everything was back then!”
You're not late to bitcoin. You're incredibly early. What we have now is just a glimpse of what's possible. Whatever the equivalents of Amazon, Google, and Facebook will be in the bitcoin space haven't even been created yet.
The next decade of bitcoin will make the previous one look like a mere prelude. The really important work - the work that will transform the global financial system - hasn't even begun yet. So no, you haven't missed bitcoin. In fact, you're just in time to be part of its most important phase: the phase where we transform it from merely speculation into the future of money.
The frontier is still wide open. The most important opportunities haven't been taken.
You are not late.
Inspired by Kevin Kelly’s classic blog post You Are Not Late. With gratitude to the GOAT!
I'm in Kuala Lumpur right now and I recently went to what was billed as a "Bitcoin" meetup.
It was an interesting cast of characters there, a lot of apparently big names in the Malaysian tech and entrepreneurial scene. (One presenter asked "does anyone here not know who I am?" and I was the only person out of 100ish who raised my hand lol).
The thing that struck me was there were only a few other guys there who were actual Bitcoiners, and if they were Maxis they didn't want to talk about that in that group.
Most of these people were working on Ethereum and Solana based startups whose function I couldn't understand in the least, even when I spoke to them at length about what problem these companies and apps were supposed to actually solve. Several of them involved NFT anime type characters which they encouraged us to snatch up while we still could.
Many were curious what this random out of place American dude was doing at the meetup. When I told them I was a long term Bitcoin holder and enthusiast, they sort of treated me as a "cute" old-fashioned fellow, gave me a figurative pat on the head, and "good for you."
I don't know quite what to make of that experience, but I think it relates in some way to the We Are Still Early reality-meme. (WASE)
I think many smart and tech-savvy people feel like they were late to Bitcoin, so they chase the next big thing, and try to outsmart everyone else in some sense. And maybe they are too caught up in the flashy jargon and bells/ whistles of Blockchain™ technology, rather than focused on how it can actually apply in normal people's lives?
I'm struggling to come up with an analogy to what these guys are up to.. are they ahead of their time in some way, like working on the pets.com or similar early 2000's dotcom startups that failed then, but exist now that the internet is more mature?
Are they Betamax enthusiasts? The Betamax was superior tech on paper but just lost the adoption race.
Or are they missing the plot entirely because they never understood the fundamentals of what Bitcoin was invented for in the first place? So they are down some strange dead end path inventing Segway scooters that are "definitely-gonna-change-the world-bro"?
I guess what I'm asking is, where does all the shitcoinery and Blockchain™ tech fit in to this WASE idea? Why are so many smart people missing what seems so obvious to us?
Maybe things are about to shift right now, and the blockchainers will start to realize that they chose the wrong horse, and migrate over. Bitcoin seems like it's starting to go mainstream but it's always hard to tell if I'm just in my own bubble.
reply
reply
do u think that this graph is accurate for world-wide view of people regarding bitcoin? i believe that the actual graph is skewed to the right (i.e. the peak is further to the left, longer tail to the right). this is from my everyday experience locally, so maybe that's only my locale distribution.
reply
It’s just a dumb meme I made lol. But according to op only 1% of the global population has ever used it, so there’s probably a sub-group of people, “Bitcoin is NGU technology but i don’t care about the far reaching consequences” 1 or 2 SDs above the average. If you’re thinking like op as in Bitcoin is still early you’re probably among the 0.1% or third standard deviation above average.
reply
i don't think of bitcoin as money only; money is only one function that this technology can fulfill. furthermore, i think the idea of money as we know it has to become obsolete, eliminated. value in its original meaning is a much better term, imho. value as in what gives people strength, valor.
reply
37 sats \ 0 replies \ @dk OP 21 Nov
I like the idea of reimagining what value means to us. I would describe value (or even money) as a coordinated record to help people collaborate on a planetary scale.
Money today is an attempt to track the contributions and debts that are given/owed to people by society/civilization.
Unfortunately, the major systems in use are not very transparent or easily interoperable at a planetary scale. So moving to a more transparent and neutral system of record keeping will be foundational for improving transparency at higher-built layers.
reply
The real adoption curve begins when bitcoin becomes invisible.
this will be so cool, life will seems magical, yet the few in the know will know how the magic came about, and how much work it takes to maintain. similar to the diabolical illusion we have today, but in a good way, haha! today, inflation seems like dark magic to people.
reply
42 sats \ 1 reply \ @alt 21 Nov
This almost makes me sad in a way. When Bitcoin is mass-adopted I want people to know!
I want them to know why the fiat system failed, why all the economic problems were caused by fiat money, and why Bitcoin has replaced it. I want them to appreciate the benefits of sound money and a free market for capital.
reply
168 sats \ 0 replies \ @dk OP 21 Nov
I agree it's important for people in the future to know and remember the problems that fiat caused so that they don't repeat the same mistakes.
That being said, the best technology's always abstract complexity in foundational layers so that the people who use it don't have to know everything about it.
reply
What else are freaks going to store their money in? Fruit Rollups?
And shoutout to Nostr News!
reply
20 sats \ 1 reply \ @dk OP 21 Nov
"tropical tie-dye bucks"
reply
reply
The way only a few institutions are going behind adoption of Bitcoin. It's still very very early. Thanks for the igniting post.
reply
Man - I am having some really existential thoughts about this one...
I mean even the definition of Late depends upon the system from which you are measuring? Every instant you are alive...you are late for your own funeral? From the perspective of the dead....if there is such a thing?
I think the reason so many humans fall into this trap of thinking they are late to something is due simply to how we have measured everything in our lives up to 1/3/09. Until Bitcoin's release into cyberspace measuring anything over long periods of time was subject to the system being used to measure it...think about how long it took to agree upon standard units of measure...height based upon "hands"...
We now have the ability to not just set something in stone, but set it in the blockchain... That information being recorded is immutable and eternal. (Period)
We have never - in the history of man - been able to record something and know that it will be there forever for all who come after us to see and learn from.
Late...sheesh... Imagine thinking you are late to learning how to read/write because the printing press was invented 600ish years ago so...no one is going to write a book anymore? Well we all know that isn't true...
Anyway - not sure where I was going with that other than to say - I agree with you - we are not late - we have just made the first atomic stratch in the infinitely large blochchain of the future and none of us have even the slightest idea of what that future will look like beyond that which we are building towards now.
reply
It's never too late. In fact, we're early. Yes, very cliché but very true.
reply
This is a fantastic post!!!
reply
74 sats \ 0 replies \ @dk OP 21 Nov
thanks for reading and appreciating! 🫡
reply
No one in the real work has much of a clue or cares much. I even work in IT!
reply
10 sats \ 1 reply \ @dk OP 22 Nov
so you agree?
reply
Yeah for the most part we are so early! I’m obsessed and with $100k here, friends are finally reaching out with some interest. I knew two guys mining who got the 50 BTC block rewards and in think they sold them all a long time ago. They were in it to learn about blockchain.
reply
Bitcoin (BTC) exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in the United States have collectively crossed $100 billion in net assets for the first time, managing approximately $104 billion as of November 21, according to Bloomberg Intelligence. This marks a significant milestone for the cryptocurrency industry, which has seen rapid institutional adoption since spot Bitcoin ETFs launched in January.
reply
0 sats \ 1 reply \ @suraz 21 Nov
This is great post. Thank you for sharing!
reply
10 sats \ 0 replies \ @dk OP 21 Nov
thanks for taking the time to read and appreciate it! 🫡
reply
Thank you for your information. And I also think that we are not late for bitcoin ecosystem as it still has many unfinished ideas as the new global currency.
reply
I learned from @DarthCoin that bitcoin is not a currency. Now I can't find the post but he shared an image with the differences.
reply
found it!
reply
thanks for sharing. I had never seen this, but it gives me more to think about
reply
Thank u for your effort.
reply