Yes, I think that's a good way to frame the debate. And I guess my pov is that it's too early to define bitcoin as a simple thing like "money". We should be more open-minded.

thesis - antithesis - synthesis; bitcoin will continue to suck until people recognize that continuing to create controversies is an obstacle to progress; really, bitcoin is the reflection of bitcoiners' mindset... admittedly tho, it sucks less than the rest of the world;