pull down to refresh

Got the idea from episode 56 of the β€œWhat Is Your Bitcoin Story?” podcast and thought it was a good chance to ask the stackers and get my very first poll in. πŸ˜ŽπŸ€™

Discovery28.6%
Invention 71.4%
42 votes \ poll ended

Both. Elements of Bitcoin, like PoW, are so fundamental that an alien race would probably have invented it too. However the ideosyncracies of exactly how Bitcoin works, like the details of the scripting system, are so specific if you don't call them "inventions", then nothing is an invention.

reply

Of course an invention.

reply

discovery, like solving math problems - the solution was always there.

reply

I think of inventions as relatively improbable discoveries which might explain why questions like this are weird to answer - it's both.

reply

I can see that.

reply
reply

btc is an invention. while encryption and cryptocurrencies existed before satoshi nakamoto.

his innovation was solving the double spending problem on a decentralized network

reply

I think it is the most significant invention of recent times... ⚑🍊

reply

The word invent means to create something that didn't exist before.

But you can't really have invention without discovery. So it's actually both.

reply

It depends how you look at it. Bitcoin is timeless in nature and that's why I look at it as a discovery

reply

For those saying that Satoshi invented bitcoin, he didn't, bitcoin is a group of technologies that already existed; he didn't invented anything. For example, he didn't invented timestamp (aka blockchain), it was already invented, he discovered a new way to group certain projects (hashcash, blind signatures, timestamp, pgp) and make it work.

reply

What matters more is this: were aliens involved?

reply

Probably every invention was a discovery.

reply

Any invention can be NP reduced to a discovery.

Inventions are recursively enumerable. Any paper corresponds to a natural number, including Satoshi's. He discovered a good one.

reply

I fall on the max keiser way of thinking here : it’s discovery is a gift to humanity, the timing, the anonymity and selflessness of satoshi and the tying together of all the values that Bitcoin represents.

reply

We all know invention

reply

Well, since I started my journey in Bitcoin, I have known that it comes from cryptography, which is a study from a long time ago and that the person or people who invented it based themselves on that, looking for what was called a new digital currency or digital money.

reply

For me it qualifies as an invention. Even though all of its pieces had already been invented. The mere act of putting them together and creating such a wonderful piece of technology qualifies as an invention.