Disclaimer: I’m going to present on Using Gen-AI tools to enhance English teaching and learning to fellow educators next Monday. Suffice it to say that I embrace the invasion of Gen-AI tools.
Preparing for the presentation reminded me of how Hayao Miyazaki famously declared his disdain for Gen-Ai tools. Aside from his exceptional talent and unparalleled work ethics, I do think that he is in a privileged position to let nature run its course, have ideas slowly germinate and marinate inside his mind, and embark on drafts and revisions before he is satisfied with his final product. Which will be top-notch and perhaps groundbreaking, that goes without saying.
Did you know that your child’s report card remarks may not be completely written by his or her teachers anymore? Platforms like Magic School help busy teachers churn out remarks in a jiffy. More motivated ones will adapt these remarks to add a personal touch; their stressed-out counterparts will probably copy and paste these remarks on the school management portal.
Because these remarks are good enough. I don’t think that many teachers lack the will to come up with personalised remarks, but given that we wear multiple hats and fulfill a multitude of tasks every day, we might not have the cognitive energy required to come up with heart-felt and insightful remarks. Insight is a time-consuming process, but time is the commodity that teachers lack.
So, sometimes I only have 15 mins before the next lesson. I could be more efficient, I guess. I may succumb to dillydallying after a lesson and only waking up my idea when time tightens its suffocating grip on me. Though I argue that I’m just human and need to decompress after an exhausting lesson and just lay back and eat something. Other times, I get dragged into conversations I may not particularly care for, but my colleagues may need help, so I will be there for them. However, these disruptions mean that I settle for good enough.
So, I use Gamma to generate PPT slides, as well as Magic School to generate worksheets. I hastily scan through AI’s work, make a few crucial changes, hit ‘Send’, and rush my way to class. I do my best with the materials I churn out. Sometimes, I’m even an effective teacher because some students remember what I say and learn to apply the strategies taught on the next assignment.
Not sure where I’m going with this. Maybe because I have no resolution in mind. I guess I envy the likes of Hayao Miyazaki who not only know what they want, but have also carved out a conducive environment for them to pursue wholeheartedly their vision, heedless of time’s march and money’s pressures.
Being a teacher, everything you said in this post resonates with me.
However, while teaching in a college presents a scenario where a teacher needs to be more creative in his selection of method for his lecture. I don't see any value for college or higher grade students teaching through AI. So, I am clear that AI can't replace teachers
reply
I think AI won’t replace teachers, but I can imagine myself using AI tools to prepare lessons for college-bound students too. Take for instance using Gemini to summarise key points of YouTube videos or give definitions of vocab words
reply
What about grading? Maybe AI can take over grading papers and exams. Or make every exam multiple choice lol
reply
Yes, sure. I have not met a single teacher who love to write question papers for exams. It's boring and time consuming.
reply
AI doesnt understand the nuances of the english language. I experimented with this before.
reply
Actually, the Singapore education system has already launched a ShortAnswerFeedbackAssistant to help teachers grade students’ writing. But ofc, human inputs are still required as this AI tool just picks up the surface-level errors like punctuation grammar spelling
reply
Everyone learns differently and teacher is one of the options. Videos, listening, reading, writing, practicals and now AI
reply
Considering that many people self-taught themselves via YouTube tutorials, I’m inclined to agree with you
reply