Isnt it because they borrow from it though? It should be highly positive with all the growth we have had in our economy in the past. Just amazes me how mismanaged the money is.
Not really, but sort of. There was some fake accounting that was called the social security trust fund, but it was never legally binding in any way and the program was never actually set up to be financially sustainable.
On occasion, politicians have publicly justified their reckless spending as borrowing from that fake trust fund, though.
reply
31 sats \ 49 replies \ @Cje95 7 May
It was sustainable as long as the population kept increasing... ironically illegal immigration is really great at helping social security stay afloat since those individuals can never draw down from it
reply
Just like how pyramid schemes are sustainable.
What I mean is analogous to how defined contribution retirement plans are sustainable, but defined benefit plans are not. There was never a social security trust fund that mechanically contained all of the money or assets that would eventually get paid out. It was always organized like an unfunded liability, even if there was occasionally money somewhere that someone claimed was for social security payments.
reply
I just dont understand why they would sell the concept and then ruin it for the people in need. I just leaves a bad taste in your mouth.
reply
They didn't ruin anything. They still make all the payments.
All that's happened is that the accounting (which was always fake) looks different now.
reply
Right now they are able to. Isnt it in a few years, next 10 years, when stuff will get difficult and they will only give 60% benefits or something?
reply
31 sats \ 41 replies \ @Cje95 7 May
Kinda... what they are going to do is raise the age to start off with because that is they easiest. Humans live longer and with social security, the idea was people only lied 3-5 years on it and died... not 20+
reply
Do you think raising the age is easier than means testing? I would have assumed the opposite.
what? They were only supposed to live 3 to 5 years on it? I thought it was a pension plan for the old.
There's nothing in the law that currently allows that. As it stands, they will keep paying out the full benefits by running huge deficits.
There are some emerging political frictions along generational lines that make me wonder how long it will be before the Boomers get their entitlements cut, though.
reply
Its only a matter of time before the major bickering starts. They never seem to be able to accomplish much.
Do illegal immigrants actually pay into it though?
reply
Yeah, I hear it on the fake news quite a bit. Actually, I remember an old coworker complaining that it isnt money the government should be touching.
reply
10 sats \ 3 replies \ @Cje95 7 May
I mean all the worlds money is whats funny is that the US is one of the best at it given its economic size compared to China and India.
reply
Its just because the dollar is trusted. Once it loses that trust, it will be a massive free for all.
reply
10 sats \ 1 reply \ @Cje95 7 May
I would agree however one thing I have learned is that what makes the dollar worth anything is the US military. If you think the US military is going to collapse like Russia then you can think that the dollar is collapsing however given the sheer size and lethality of the military the dollar will remain stronger than most just due to the fact of in conflict you might hit the US once but the US will make you bleed for generations to come
reply
haha No way will Americas army collapse. There are always lemmings willing to join up, just like 9/11. Nothing against people that join the military.
reply