In 2022, of all app store takedowns requested by government, Apple literally complied with China 1435 times, which represented 97.3% of all requests worldwide.
Apps removed from the App Store subject to
government takedown demands
1474
By country or region
• China mainland: 1435
• India: 14
• Pakistan: 10
• Russia: 7
• Türkiye: 2
• Bulgaria: 1
• Cyprus: 1
• Hong Kong: 1
• Italy: 1
• Latvia: 1
• Nigeria: 1
They did this to Damus for example, when it listed. It's probably one of the easiest ways China can enforce a ringfenced Internet besides adding IP addresses to the Great Firewall. One of the reasons BTC/Nostr can be resilient is plenty of non-app store options to access. Also a good reminder that app store configuration/choice is a vital part of making technologies anti-censorship resilient.
I would say SimpleX Chat is the best choice for privacy. It is alway e2e encrypted, leaks less metadata than Signal, has enabled post quantum encryption, and has no user identifiers. It’s only downfall right now is large group chats but they are working on solutions that should land later this year.
Telegram is a bad chat app for privacy. It’s less secure than WhatsApp. (Always on E2E).
I’ve no idea how they convinced a bunch of cryptocurrency enthusiasts it’s secure — because it isn’t.
It is default unencrypted
all group chats are unencrypted
Only phone to phone 1:1 is encrypted in “secret chat mode”, which nobody uses.
Basically anything you write on telegram is unlikely to actually be encrypted such that only you and your counterparty can read it.
Signal is the correct answer if you want a private, secure messenger.
Closed source yes, but its not exactly under Russian control. The servers are not in Russia, and neither is the corp or Durov. Durov renounced his Russian citizenship.
I don't think its fair to say its under Russia control.
That Russia blocked it from 2018, and then permitted it from 2020 is a little suspect however. It would suggest selective access may exist.