I just had a conversation with a gas station owner about the idea of accepting Bitcoin as a form of payment. He emphasized the importance of the off-ramping function in Euro for his business. For merchants dealing in goods with potentially high tax components, negative currency fluctuations understandably pose a concern.
On the flip side, merchants offering services seemed to experience less pain from direct off-ramping in Euro. I believe there should be more avenues for businesses to spend their Bitcoin, including in wholesale and telecommunications fox example.
However, it's personally disheartening to see Bitcoin converted back to fiat, regardless of who initiates the exchange. What questions or concerns do the merchants you speak with typically have?
From some merchants I've talked to, they seem to not want the accounting mess with receiving bitcoin payments, which I can understand. Like @siggy47 said, there's just a lot of BS in the way, though there are the noble few who take on the challenge.
reply
I undertand! Fortunately, I don't encounter this issue, as the solution I offer includes transaction reporting for tax purposes.
reply
Yes, the hardest part in convincing a merchant is their misconception of BTC "volatility". Very few really understand the part where BTC is the "savings machine" and not the "get rich" one.
I always explain them that we are still early and even if the would have 10% from their income in BTC, is still a good thing to keep them as savings.
Later in time, they could start spending from this reserve, when is really needed, on employees salaries, paying a local supplier, paying a handy-man for a repair etc things like these, that do not affect too much their cash-flow but in the same time are slowly creating that Bitcoin circular economy.
Saying that you must convert your BTC instantly for fiat, is a clear message that your business will not survive anyways in such a rampant inflation ball-rolling. In other words they are really dumb and don't even know how to run properly a business.
Later they will regret it. ALL THE TIME they regret it. I had dozens of them calling me back after years, saying that they regret selling their BTC.
I have no more other words for those than:
reply
Its complicated.. Business operates under slim margins. Many have way less than 10% of profit after taxes.. Even that 10% can represent a lot.. When you add the volatility or the btc taxes.. Numbers simply doesnt add up.. Its probably the number 1 problem for business adoption.. Giant tech companies do not have this problem as often they have higher margins and less taxes..
reply
The question is also whether merchants in the current situation can or want to make significant reserves in Bitcoin if they haven't fully understood it yet.
In some conversations, I've noticed that a split, like half in fiat and half in Bitcoin, definitely sparks interest.
reply
deleted by author
reply
OMG what a terrible story!
reply
This sounds like a challenging experience, especially when you invest your own time in it. Nevertheless, I would recommend persevering and continuing!
reply
deleted by author
reply
When people like this want to sell, I have managed sometimes to convince them to at least not sell 100%, but like 90%, keep some, you are in fiat profit anyway.
reply
yeah sometimes I have the same feeling, what's the point if I am the only one using it? We have to be all in this if we want to go further. Is fucking hard with merchants.
I don't know, maybe I was lucky but few years ago I found a good merchants that I convince him and from then was just easy for me, I pay all my necessary stuff through him.
reply
Here in the U.S. paperwork is a big hurdle, in addition to the usual general ignorance about bitcoin. Many businesses deal with sales tax issues, conversion capital gains tax, etc. It seems that only merchants with a strong commitment to bitcoin are willing to address the challenges.
reply
Then, helping to strengthen the commitment becomes the mission as usual, haha!
reply
As most people agree... is the fiat mentality with all the TAX related bureaucracy, so you need to understand first that you are accepting bitcoin to don't give a shit about a government, you are building wealth.
What I heard?
  • I want to accept BTC and "sell" for fiat quickly
  • What can I buy with it?
When you accept that you are building your wealth, you as a merchant only want btc to stack, and in (we hope) near future spend in circular economy, all the other things seems irrelevant and a compliance with the actual system that... it's just fuck up.
reply
Yes! I also believe that being ready as a merchant to hold Bitcoin privately or as an asset in the company is a different matter. I think these are two stages that come one after the other.
reply
21 sats \ 1 reply \ @OT 11 Dec 2023
I have a local cafe interested in accepting bitcoin. The problem is everything that comes with doing lightning properly like opening a channel, then swapping some out.
The other issue of converting back to fiat or splitting the payment up is not that easy either. There are some wallets that can do that, but are not optimally designed as a point of sale.
They really need to learn about bitcoin first. Or they can just use wallet of satoshi
reply
The question always remains whether, as a merchant, one can find the time and technical expertise to operate a node, especially when they need to be at the wholesaler by 5 AM and then clean the store in the evening.
Fortunately, there are already several providers in the market putting a lot of effort into offering merchants a great Lightning experience. Such options can certainly be highlighted in conversations with merchants.
reply
In Spain is not easy for the merchant if they want to do it legally... From a fiscal advisor (José Antonio Bravo):
"This is what a business needs to do to accept payments in BTC. You can create the invoice in Euros (which is what the tax authorities care about) and include the conversion to the equivalent in BTC. However, you must consider that this will be the acquisition price of the BTC so that, when you sell them, you can calculate whether there has been a gain or loss.
In addition to the above, you must account for the BTC in an accounting entry in accordance with its future destination.
If you are planning to convert them into euros within a period of less than a year, you should record the entries in an Inventory account (since they are not money, nor financial assets), and maintain this inventory account by the speculative method. That is, the inventory enters at the purchase price and exits at the selling price at the time of its conversion to euros, or its exchange for other goods or services (including exchanges for other cryptocurrencies). At the end of the year, a regularization of inventory is performed based on the remaining units at that time at their value (this can be done, for example, through Cointracking), and the difference, positive or negative, is taken to results.
However, if you intend to hold the cryptocurrencies as an investment, you should record the entry as Fixed Assets, with the particular characteristic that, being assets without depreciation over time (as could happen with land), their value cannot be amortized. It would be advisable to detail them by batches of different prices. When it is decided to sell these assets in exchange for money or other goods or services, it would be convenient to change their categorization to Inventory."
reply
That's a nightmare of self-reading you've commented on here.
reply
Sorry. Spain is not an easy country for BTC adoption from the merchant side.
reply
Don't be sorry, as @DarthCoin would say!!!
However, I am convinced that progress will be made in the EU in the coming years. Even though I wish it were already the case.
Good luck for you! Hope the weather is nice in Spain
Aside from all the usual obstacles to adoption, one specific concern from one business owner friend of mine was about the risk of receiving stolen bitcoin as payment. Specifically, he was worried about law enforcement coming to retrieve/confiscate those UTXOs later. Liquidating all received bitcoin would be one way to handle this concern. I also asked him if the same risk doesn't exist with dollars/cash, because I have no idea.
reply
I got encouraged by Darthcoin to talk to half a dozen merchants where it would be really really valuable to me if they had Lightning ⚡
Didn't recieve an answer yet. I fear that all these customer support Email adresses go straight into "JIRA ticket closed”.
Very unfortunate, idk what to do... 😔
reply
I believe personal contact is truly crucial here. As much as I appreciate your efforts via email, I think the return on investment in terms of time for onboarded merchants might be quite low.
Trotzdem gute Tat, dran bleiben!
reply
I have never embarked on this journey personally
reply
Getting the right price conversion between fiat and Bitcoin
reply
Telling them to leave fiat is the major bottleneck
reply
In my country Kenya 95% of adults don't know or understand bitcoin. Talking to merchants about bitcoin here is a waste of time.Me and my friends are creating a couple of online forums to make more people bitcoin savvy.
reply
The biggest barrier I've encountered is knowledge. People don't know what bitcoin is. They also don't know what to do with it. They usually link it with pyramid schemes and other "get rich quick" scams.
This is mostly related to the frequent news related to cryptocurrencies in general and how the press "paints" this stuff to the public.
reply
I've also noticed that, and I always recommend various self-learning apps where you can even earn a few sats while educating yourself with Bitcoin knowledge.
reply
In my experience it's always come down to a combination the below 4 things (to varying degrees):
  1. suppliers don't accept bitcoin
  2. margins are too tight( see #1 )
  3. lack of technical understanding to handle bitcoin confidently
  4. confusing tax structure
reply
One concern is that the merchants we onboard get their bank accounts shutdown for being listed on btcmap.
Even just the threat of it by the notnilc system is enough to scare people off.
reply
My experience is that the following prevent businesses from accepting bitcoin payments:
  • volatility of the price
  • liquidity of the asset (i.e. off-ramping difficulty)
  • technical challenges of learning
  • taxes are annoying to calculate
  • bookkeeping is more difficult
  • many think it is a scam
When chatting with merchants, their concerns often revolve around the practicalities of integration, security, and potential tax implications. They're curious about customer demand for Bitcoin payments and the tools available for smooth transitions. Some wonder about the infrastructure needed to handle crypto transactions efficiently and securely. How do you see businesses adapting to these concerns in the near future?
reply
Thank you for your comment. I don't believe that the doubts of merchants will change. Instead, I think there will be more companies emerging that can solve these issues through their offered services.
reply