I don’t know. It’s hard for me to say that. Gretzky piled on his numbers with generational talent in Edmonton. Can you name any of Sidney’s linemates during his run? Most people will say Malkin but they were a one two punch. 

I’m not saying Wayne isn’t the GOAT but Sid deserves some consideration 

I agree Ruby but Gretzky in his era was far better than all until Marion showed up. Sidney was the best but by a little. Gretzky last season still led the Rangers in scoring in this new era transition. Don't forget those seasons had good defending too. The Devils remember, so Gretzky would be Gretzky now too

Meani123

Stacker_Sports

Should Sidney Crosby be in the GOAT 🐐 talk?

BlokchainB

Comparing eras is always hard. Yeah, who knows. Certainly wouldn't have racked up that many points as there is less scoring now but would he still have been as dominant. Hard to say. 