pull down to refresh

Here's a rad markets-are-wacky thing:
That's TSMC's stock—the one traded in Taiwan vs New York. They're exactly (-ish) the same instrument, but at times there's a spread opening up... recently it's been upwards of $150 billion of difference in market cap.
My econ brain goes: ARBITRAGE, LAW OF ONE PRICE... Small differences or discrepancies can happen here and there, sure whatevs, but $150bn in the 10th largest stock on the planet?!

My god, what is going ON?!

Nobody has a very good answer, but Wigglesworth traces an interesting candidate:
DE Shaw’s view is that it boils down to an acute bank balance sheet shortage. In other words, the supply of financing available to arbitrageurs from banks is simply too limited at the moment. It’s like you can see the juicy unspoilt apples at the top of a tree, but the hardware shop has run out of the ladders needed to pick them.

"what looks like a gross violation of LOOP is actually the rising cost of renting bank balance sheets getting baked into market prices."

If there's an acute bank balance sheet/capacity shortage... is there gonna be a HUGE BIG PRINT coming?! (#914600).
Mr. Wiggly ends on the same note:
Alphaville does wonder what the apparently extreme tightness of bank balance sheets might mean at a sensitive time for financial markets as a whole.

"arbitrageurs" - Dope word
Have you ever looked at the spreads in bitcoin prices across different currencies?
@Coinsreporter was showing me a pretty substantial spread between bitcoin/USD and bitcoin/INR (after accounting for USD/INR, obvs) and I was wondering the same thing.
reply
never... all I remember on that is the kimshi trade back in the day...
So... same question to @Coinsreporter, then: why? How aren't people just milking that perpetual financial motion machine?
reply
People were doing it till there was a loophole. Now they've taxed any sort of Bitcoin donation 30% and profits 34%.
I can only transfer very limited fiat to overseas.
Before 2022, we could do P2P without coming into notice through foreign exchanges which didn't require KYC. Now they all do it. So that's the problem.
Even 1 dollar has arbitrage here. When I do P2P I get 90 INR for 1 USD which is 4 INR more than the actual price.
Still, as I said before, if we can find a way to non KYC P2P Bitcoin sell in India and buy in USD, we can be sitting on a big money very soon. The difference just blows my mind.
reply
He didn't know. My guess was basically the same as the explanation in this piece: some sort of friction in the financial markets.
reply
Wow! If it lasted for a few days or even weeks I might not be surprised, but it looks like the spread has been significant for over a year!
Could bank balance sheet shortages really explain it?
Maybe something about capital controls? I know Taiwan restricts its capital outflows pretty tightly. BTW, which one is which, red and blue?
reply
The red line is TSMC stock in New York (the blue in Taiwan).
There was some mention in the piece, too, about how the gap could stem from passive flow from brokerage accounts/investment policies in the U.S., that limits investment in certain types of assets-
reply