pull down to refresh

Making a brief lil entry in this wonderful territory I have on mute (who cares about sports?!), because The Economist is running a Magnus Carlsen op-ed—and chess definitely (maybe?) qualifies as sport! (Magnus = LeBron, or Tom Brady, or Wayne Gretzky; just the unbeatable and unquestionably best the game has probably ever seen.)
Why freestyle? Following my fifth consecutive victory in the World Chess Championship in 2022, I announced that I would no longer defend the title. Many speculated that I was exhausted, or that I was scared of the next generation of players. On the contrary, my passion for chess remains as strong as ever, and I am as ambitious as I’ve always been. What changed was my perspective on the format of the classical world championship itself.
So freestyle chess, for the uninitiated, is a version of standard chess where the back rank of pieces are shuffled randomly (subject to some rules, i.e. bishops of opposite colors; king in-between the rooks).

This avoids all forms of opening repertoire, the memorization of which has become the main way to get ahead in the top echelons of competitive chess.

Freestyle Chess lowers barriers to entry for aspiring players, by diminishing a reliance on exhaustive, theoretical study and on access to high-performance computing. This opens opportunities for underrepresented regions that brim with untapped talent and enthusiasm. In the same way that young Brazilians kick around a football on dusty patches with dreams of going further, we are going to see young folk in Africa and elsewhere turning to chess in a much bigger way.
Here's Magnus' objection to exactly that tendency of top chess:
The issue lay elsewhere, in the months of grinding preparation leading up to the event. Modern World Chess Championships demand endless memorisation of computer-generated opening lines, reducing the sport’s artistry to rote learning. As someone who treasures the creativity of chess, I wanted to focus more on this aspect of the game. [...] the players must rely on intuition, creativity and raw mental acuity—qualities I believe embody the essence of chess.
What's so interesting to see is that games, as soon as move 4 or so, can end up in compleeetely lost positions—and there's plenty more dynamics, with lots of chaos on the board. Very fun for the players; even more fun for us amateurs to watch.
Also, Fabiano Caruana, another top-player and one-time challenger for Magnus' title, is know to have insane heart rates during games (there was recently a one-to-one game between him and Magnus in Singapore, where they measured their heart rates... Fabi crazy; Magnus like he's asleep):
We even monitored heart rates, providing a novel layer of drama. At one critical moment Fabiano’s pulse spiked to 170 beats a minute, while I was pleased to remain comparatively calm under pressure.
Freakin wonderful drawing of our dude too:

non-paywalled here: https://archive.md/RxVJw
I had never heard of freestyle chess. I love the idea.
reply
It's also called Chess960, because there are 960 possible starting positions, iirc.
reply
I was never interested in learning the sequences of openings and closings, which makes it hard to play chess with anyone who enjoys chess.
I recall a study that showed even master chess players aren't much better than average, when starting with randomized boards.
reply
I wonder what level of players that study used though, because a fascinating thing about Chess960 tournaments is that a lot of the best classical players still end up at the top.
reply
It's been a while since I saw it, but they weren't even doing Chess960. They were actually randomly placing pieces on the board, often in configurations that never occur in a real game.
The other part I'm wondering about now is power. Even if there were no statistically significant advantage found in the study, that doesn't mean there's not enough real advantage to see a difference over the course of a tournament.
reply
Might be a different effect, 1-50, 50-99th percentilen versus the top 1 or top 0.001%
reply
Might be true.
Most of my advancing up the (chess.com) ranks was from learning a handful of openings really well.
I mean, I still hang my queen now and again to completely fuck myself, but I do get very nice/dominant positions
reply
or Fischer Random
It was Bobby Fischer who introduced it, because he was sick spending so much time on opening memory.
reply
reply
aka Chess960 / aka Fisher Random Chess
Bobby Fisher is generally credited with "inventing" or "promoting" this idea.
He became hugely negative on chess later in life and basically stopped playing. His thought was that it was all just route memorization of openings - this is what Chess960 seeks to solve.
reply
45 sats \ 3 replies \ @gmd 10 Feb
I dunno why I don't have much of a desire to watch this. I like having the pieces where they are...
I think Blitz/Rapid preserves the game while making it more interesting for fans and spectators.
reply
I think there's something to the idea that if you play chess, watching classical feels more familiar, and you have more of a sense of "what would I do in this position?", or "oh, why did they go here instead of there?"
Whereas watching Fischer Random you're just kinda shrugging like "i have no idea what's going on but they're Super GMs so they must know what they're doing."
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @gmd 10 Feb
Yeah seems great for Super GMs but it's hard for a casual like me to relate to...
reply
definitely also true;
There was a tournament a few years back where players played like 1 hour of 5 minute games; 30 min of 3 min games; and 15 min of 1 minute games. That was incredibly entertaining
reply
Freestyle chess sounds kinda fun. Thanks for slumming with us in Sports for a bit.
reply
Honored to be here, great sir!
reply
Computer analysis says all classical chess games end up with draw position and this fact makes chess boring, especially if you're grandmaster. Freestyle a.k.a. Fisher chess will make chess great again. I'm really grateful Magnus made this statement
reply
Interesting! Never knew chess also has another version called freestyle.
reply