pull down to refresh

Fill in the blanks with a single digit such that the resulting sentence is true.
"In this sentence, the number of occurences of the digit 0 is ______, of the digit 1 is ______, of the digit 2 is ______, of the digit 3 is ______, of even numbers is ______, of odd numbers is ______, and of prime numbers is ______."
Previous iteration: #743084 (answer in #743754). Also, @Scroogey ended up solving the puzzle from 2 days ago: #741908
Brute force finds two solutions:
1 2 3 2 5 6 7 1 2 3 2 6 5 6
reply
I think it's an impossible problem to solve!
reply
This would be an impossible variant to this self-referential problem:
"In this sentence, the number of occurences of the digit 0 is ______, of the digit 1 is ______, of the digit 2 is ______, of even numbers is ______, of odd numbers is ______, and of prime numbers is ______."
(notice the omission of the digit 3 part)
reply
What's wrong with either of my solutions?
reply
In this sentence, the number of occurences of the digit 0 is 1, of the digit 1 is 2, of the digit 2 is 3, of the digit 3 is 2, of even numbers is 5, <---- of odd numbers is 6, and of prime numbers is 7.
In this sentence, the number of occurences of the digit 0 is 1, of the digit 1 is 2, of the digit 2 is 3, of the digit 3 is 2, of even numbers is 6, <---- of odd numbers is 5, and of prime numbers is 6.
I'm considering that 0 is neither even nor odd
reply
I think zero is generally considered even as it can be divided by two without remainder.
reply
Since the number zero is even, both are correct!
reply
Reasoned solution:
Let the blanks be filled in with a_0, a_1, a_2, a_3, a_{\text{ev}}, a_{\text{od}}, and a_{\text{pr}}, respectively. Among these, the first four entries satisfy a_i \geq 1 for i \leq 3, while the other three entries each satisfy a \geq 2. Thus, a_0 = 1, a_1 \geq 2, and a_{\text{od}} \geq 3. Given a_{\text{ev}} + a_{\text{od}} = 11, the values have opposite parity, so there’s at least one additional even and odd entry. Consequently, a_{\text{ev}} \geq 3 and a_{\text{od}} \geq 4. This limits (a_{\text{ev}}, a_{\text{od}}) to only five pairs: (3,8), (4,7), (5,6), (6,5), or (7,4). Each pair has exactly one prime number, hence a_{\text{pr}} \geq 3, but a_{\text{pr}} \neq 3, as this β€œ3” would add a fourth prime to the set, implying a_{\text{pr}} \geq 4.
Now, only a_2 and a_3 are potential placements for β€œ1,” so a_1 \leq 4. If a_1 = 4, there are three primes, including one from (a_{\text{ev}}, a_{\text{od}}), but not a_{\text{pr}}. Setting a_{\text{pr}} = 4 would then leave only three primes, and any other a_{\text{pr}} would be too large. Thus, a_1 \leq 3. Assume a_1 = 3; then a_3 \geq 2. To assess feasibility, suppose a_3 = 2, which implies a_2 \geq 2, creating a contradiction with a_1 = 3. Thus, a_3 \geq 3. If a_3 \geq 4, a_{\text{pr}} = 3 leads to more than three primes, so a_3 = 3.
With a_3 = 3, counting primes from (a_{\text{ev}}, a_{\text{od}}) yields five primes. Setting a_{\text{pr}} = 5 results in six primes, while a_{\text{pr}} = 6 yields five primes, a contradiction. Therefore, a_1 = 2, implying a_2 \geq 3 because a_2 = 2 would introduce three β€œ2”s. Since only a_3 = 2 allows a third 2, we conclude a_2 = 3 and a_3 = 2.
Thus, we find six primes with a_{\text{pr}} = 6 or a_{\text{pr}} = 7, resulting in two possible solutions: (1, 2, 3, 2, 6, 5, 6) and (1, 2, 3, 2, 5, 6, 7).
reply
This is the answer ChatGPT gave.
"In this sentence, the number of occurrences of the digit 0 is 2, of the digit 1 is 1, of the digit 2 is 2, of the digit 3 is 1, of even numbers is 3, of odd numbers is 3, and of prime numbers is 3."
reply
Yeah, it's bad at this.
For other daily puzzles, i checked, it did arrive to the solution. But I'll just keep assuming people do it for the fun of solving rather than the few sats i give as rewards here and there. No way to police this anyhow :)
reply
I wonder why they haven't built in the capability for ChatGPT to simply say, "I don't know." The solution it gave is so obviously wrong.
(I haven't used it for previous problems, not that anyone accused me. But this one seemed especially suitable to test on chatgpt, and it failed pretty miserably.)
reply
β€œIn this sentence, the number of occurrences of the digit 0 is 1, of the digit 1 is 11, of the digit 2 is 2, of the digit 3 is 1, of even numbers is 2__, of odd numbers is 1, and of prime numbers is __2."
reply
  1. For the digit 0: Note the number of occurrences of "0" in the sentence after filling in the blanks. Example: # There are X occurrences of the digit 0.
  2. For the digit 1: Count the occurrences of "1" after filling in the blanks. Example: # There are X occurrences of the digit 1.
  3. For the digit 2: Count the occurrences of "2" after filling in the blanks. Example: # There are X occurrences of the digit 2.
  4. For the digit 3: Count the occurrences of "3" after filling in the blanks. Example: # There are X occurrences of the digit 3.
  5. For even digits: Count all even digits in the final sentence and confirm their total. Example: # There are X even digits.
  6. For odd digits: Count all odd digits in the sentence and verify their total. Example: # There are X odd digits.
  7. For prime numbers: Count the prime digits (2, 3, 5, 7) and confirm their total. Example: # There are X prime digits.
reply
23 minutes later ....
reply
sounds a bit like math gymnastics to me. :(
reply
Ain't it fun? :)
reply
In this sentence, the number of occurrences of the digit 0 is 3, of the digit 1 is 2, of the digit 2 is 2, of the digit 3 is 2, of even numbers is 5, of odd numbers is 4, and of prime numbers is 4.
reply
Once, once, once, once, once, twice, twice.
😁
reply