pull down to refresh

After this week's hiatus, hope to pick up again more regularly.

Today's question:

Is the tangent of rational, i.e.

with and integers.

Provide a proof for it.

Previous iteration: #732372

Thanks for posting this puzzle too: #734034

We can use the trigonometric addition formula

in an inductive proof by contradiction:

  • Assumption: is rational.
  • Step: if is rational then must also be rational, because the above formula is the ratio of two rational numbers.
  • But which is irrational, hence the assumption must be wrong.

tan(30)

reply

Nice job. This was supposedly an entrance exam question for the University of Kyoto in 2006.

reply

I understand the Kyodai and Todai exams are literal nightmares! They have people going to special exam schools for several years on end to get the score high enough to be accepted.

reply

Yeah looks pretty extreme. You really need to be trained on this to be able to solve this kind of problem with tight time constraints.

reply

Nice. Are you a mathematician, @Scroogey?

reply

deleted by author

reply

Pulling out an inductive proof by contradiction, along with an obscure (to me) formula, is impressive for someone who doesn't do proofs on a regular basis :)

reply

deleted by author

reply

Proof by contradiction was my favorite method in college. I think it's easier because you know where to start and you just move forward. So even to prove that things are true, I'd just assume the converse and show a contradiction.

Because a non-contradiction based proof seems harder. You know where you want to go, but you don't know where to start.

reply

Yeah, Reductio ad Absurdum were also my favorites.

reply