Germany's economic contributions to the EU far outweigh its returns, according to a recent report from the German Economic Institute. In 2023, Germany paid €17.4 billion net into the EU, more than any other member state, with France contributing nearly half that amount at just under €9 billion. Meanwhile, Poland, the largest net beneficiary, received €8.2 billion while continuing to bolster its military, with plans to maintain a force larger than those of Germany, France, the UK, and Italy combined.
Beyond direct contributions, the NextGenerationEU (NGEU) fund—heavily financed by debt and primarily backed by Germany—further skews the balance. This fund, part of the EU’s recovery plan, amounts to €806.9 billion, of which €385.8 billion are loans and €338 billion are non-repayable grants. Despite being a net contributor to the EU budget, Germany’s commitments under this fund raise its 2023 total contribution to €28.3 billion.
In stark contrast, France and Italy, although net contributors in the regular EU budget, become net recipients when the NGEU is considered. A recent study from the Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research estimates that Germany’s future liabilities for NGEU could add up to €262 billion. This could push Germany’s national debt to nearly 73% of GDP, up from the current 63%.
Germany’s role as the EU’s financial backbone is clear, but at what cost? For the Eurozone and the EU, Germany has become nothing more than a cash cow, now facing economic decline. This raises critical questions about how future socialist projects and green policies will be financed if the largest creditor and guarantor for the debts of others begins to falter systematically.