Germany is navigating a tumultuous period, with the government, led by the Green Robert Habeck and Defense Minister Boris Pistorius (SPD), spearheading a controversial shift towards a state-controlled defense sector. This strategy, which includes potential state stakes in defense companies and projects, marks a significant pivot from Germany’s traditional economic model (I've been pointing at this for several months).
Since the fall of the Soviet Union Germany's economy thrived on three pillars: cheap Russian gas, the creation of a low-wage sector, and the Euro—a currency undervalued relative to Germany’s productivity. This combination allowed for a quasi-neo-mercantilist economic system that prospered at the expense of other Eurozone members.
However, this economic model is now under severe strain. The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has revealed the fragility of Europe’s economy, particularly Germany’s. The war, which was unwinnable from the outset due to Europe’s weak and resource-poor economy, has plunged Germany into an economic downturn. Panic is spreading through European capitals as the recession deepens, with Germany, in particular, facing growing challenges and a rapid de-industrialization with record high insolvencies.
Germany had the chance to leverage cheap energy imports, such as Russian gas, and expand its nuclear sector to solve its immense demographic problems. This approach could have stabilized social security systems and maintained a growth trajectory that would allow for political flexibility. Instead, the abrupt shift away from these energy sources has left Germany struggling to maintain its economic footing, with severe consequences for its future.
As the economic situation worsens, there is a growing realization that Europe, particularly Germany, may eventually have to return to Vladimir Putin’s cheap Russian gas to prevent an economic collapse. Yet, Europe has not yet reached this point, and for now, leaders are desperately trying to involve the United States more deeply in the conflict. Historically, Europe has relied on American intervention in global conflicts, and this situation is no different. With the war in Ukraine seemingly lost, European leaders are pushing hard to draw the U.S. into the fray, hoping to shift the balance in their favor.
And now this push to establish a 'war economy' in the EU. This growing state intervention is distorting democratic principles and detracting from the state’s true responsibilities meanwhile it is crowding out the private sector even more which will come at cost of future productivity growth (which already dusappeared in the rise of the growing state interventionism and bureaucracy).
The proposal to fast-track permits for new arms factories, eliminate restrictions on state funding for defense-related projects, and increase state involvement in companies like Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems are indicative of this trend. Despite earlier setbacks, the KfW Bank is set to reassess its potential involvement in Thyssenkrupp, reflecting desperation rather than strategy. So more power in the hands of the political caste... goid luck with that!
This shift towards a state-driven economy is not new to Germany. The concept of state control over a complex economy, with the creation of a massive regulatory bureaucracy, is deeply rooted in German political thought. The current German government exemplifies the infantilization of our era and the political sphere, embodying a green apocalyptic vision and a misguided belief that a complex economy can be centrally managed. This approach is now being exported to the European Union, aligning with the EU’s broader agenda to dominate the public narrative. However, this push is leading Europe down a dangerous path, where citizens' rights, pacifism, and voter sovereignty are increasingly under threat.
The broader implications of increased state control are troubling, not just for Germany but for Europe as a whole. The European Union is on a perilous path, risking a profound erosion of citizen rights and democratic sovereignty in its quest for control. As the push for U.S. involvement intensifies, the gap between European aspirations and economic realities continues to widen, making the continent's future even more uncertain.
this territory is moderated
US involvement has never been a good thing for any country historically!
reply
So, this is why Chancellor has raised the defense budget to 2% of GDP in 2024.
reply
It gets even better: the state is once again planning to invest 100 billion euros of special funds in defense technology and armaments in a shadow budget
reply
Isn't Germany moving towards neo-communism?
reply
11 sats \ 1 reply \ @TomK OP 10 Aug
And a part of it is the green destruction
reply
Germans have to really rethink their approach towards politics. Their idleness of not raising questions against these policies is understandable!
reply
As the economic situation worsens, there is a growing realization that Europe, especially Germany, may eventually have to return to Vladimir Putin's cheap Russian gas to prevent economic collapse. However, Europe has not yet reached this point, and for now, leaders are pushing hard to involve the United States more deeply in the conflict. Historically, Europe has relied on American intervention in global conflicts, and this situation is no different. With the war in Ukraine seemingly lost, European leaders are scrambling to draw the US into the fray, hoping to shift the balance in their favor.
If you look at the current economic conditions, not only Germany, almost all countries are experiencing this. Now when we look at economic conditions, sometimes they base their charts on dollars. On average, several countries follow the dollar wave, so inevitably they have to follow the dollar economic wave.
reply
The german situation is exeptionally worse than in other european countrie or in the US. It's sad but their own fault. The data is clear in this case
reply
If I analyze, Germany used to be a developed country, this started when it appeared during the Covid era, before Covid appeared the economy was still running well, after Covid appeared there was a need for a budget to facilitate all treatment, after Covid passed this is where the economy started to be on the verge of collapse, such as difficulties in employment, finances, even food.
reply
Sorry, I don't want to draw You into the german mess but the roots of today's dramatic decline can be found in the year 2003 when Angela Merkel (WEF asset) took over and changed the direction. The green agenda has been absorbed by all gov parties since then
reply
Yes you're right
but I also appreciate that foreign countries can also judge that Germany is a developed country, maybe it can be translated
reply
Over the last 26 years I always had media clients like the liberal party or associations of entrepreneurs so that I watched this catastrophe from a seat in the first rows of the theatre. But the real downfall will start later when demografics really bite
reply
Yes, we together hope that, under pressure, the economic conditions currently experienced by Germany will soon improve. It seems there is a mastermind behind this destruction.
reply
"Everything is a rich man's trick."
reply
I'm pretty sure the Italians came up with a word for merging state and corporate power.
reply
Well... there are rumours
reply
Europe always needs the US bodies to fight the war. Another state driven economy? Like the third reich?
reply
20 sats \ 1 reply \ @TomK OP 9 Aug
yes yes, the United States as a European colony (who went to Downing Street some weeks ago to get his orders....)
as far as the war economy is concerned: the EU Europeans are once again united in repeating old mistakes of the past collectively this time. that can't go well
reply
This time Russia and China will be the enemy. We will see how things turn out. You never know, they might want to sing kumbaya.
reply