Bitcoin is the only true form of money. The rest (fiat, crypto, cbdc and etf) are scams.
In order to prove whether or not a crypto is a security, the SEC relies on precedent set by the US Supreme Court in 1946 (specifically, SEC v. W. J. Howey Co).
The so-called Howey test holds that an “investment contract” amounts to a security if three conditions are met: (1) there’s an investment of money; (2) the investment is made in a common enterprise; and (3) there’s an expectation that profits will be derived from the efforts of others.
If the token is relatively centralized, and or the team behind it has made claims about their ability to drive up its price, then the Howey test is likely to be passed.
Crucially, none of that applies to bitcoin – the world’s most decentralized digital asset, with a market cap nearly equal to all other cryptos combined, whose founder neither pre-mined any coins nor has any ongoing involvement in the project – and the SEC knows it.
“We believe every [edit] asset other than bitcoin is a scam,” the SEC supposedly told Coinbase before filing its litigation, according to paraphrased remarks by Brian Armstrong, the exchange’s chief executive.
Bitcoin is the only true form of money. The rest (fiat, crypto, cbdc and etf) are scams.
Um, no? Gold is a perfectly fine form of money, and has been for thousands of years. So has been silver, other metals and commodities. They are inferior in most aspects, sure, but Bitcoin is not perfect either, and is not the "final form" of money - there will be a successor when the needs arise and technology allows (e.g. Bitcoin is not feasible for an interstellar species).
Did you mean electronic forms of money? Or do you disregard all physical commodities as invalid?
reply
Did you mean electronic forms of money?
Electronic forms of money, indeed. The physical forms are controlled by a central entity, are not convenient for large transactions, are at risk of theft, and cannot be used for online transactions.
reply
I think this is leaking too much on one side. You cant really do a whole lot without fiat. Fiat is needed to make the world go around.
reply
Cheers. I had wondered for a while about the Howey test and why Bitcoin is not seen as a security.
reply