63 sats \ 2 replies \ @orthwyrm 7 May \ parent \ on: What would Utopia look like to you? culture
I honestly think that a lot of crime is just rooted in poverty or any reason that is 2 steps removed from the underlying reason of poverty. Ever seen a rich person steal makeup from Walmart? I doubt. That wouldn't solve all crime, sure. But we'd be a lot closer to your utopia.
however i think i push back against this claim as i think crime has more to do with inequality and poor law enforcement than anything else. i don't believe most thieves in western democracies are stealing because they are starving: they are stealing because a) they feel justified as they feel the system is rigged against them and / or b) they can get away with it.
write
preview
50 sats \ 1 reply \ @tomlaies 7 May
crime has more to do with inequality and poor law enforcement than anything else
Let's take this thought to the extreme: Everybody is rich. Everybody has a mansion in the countryside and a NYC skyscraper apartment and a dozen cars etc but the world is still unequal: Jeff Bezos has a Yacht and a private island and a personal spacestation.
You think there would still be theft? Why should anyone break into another house if they live comfortable anyways. Why should anyone waste their time patrolling the streets against home break ins or robberies?
reply
30 sats \ 0 replies \ @orthwyrm 8 May
i was thinking about your post-scarcity thought experiment last night. it's an interesting question when you push it to the extremes.
on the one hand, i am inclined to agree with you. while there are reasons to steal other than satisfying material wants (such as protest and general hooliganism), one could argue that the plebs would be so inundated with their fantastic lives that they wouldn't really notice that bezos continues to stiff them.
yet on the other hand, humans are status-oriented creatures and this is a relative game. if everyone has a yacht, but bezos has 100 yachts coated in gold, then i truly do believe that a sizable chunk of the population would feel hard done by this and would cause chaos as a result. because the goal is not to acquire yachts, but to climb the social hierarchy. and if you cannot climb it through competence (perhaps you are low-iq or uncharismatic) then you instead ascend through violence (tearing apart bezos). i think this is inherent in human nature and a rare case of "bitcoin does not fix this".
time will tell. it would be nice if you were right.
reply