No, but I want to think Menger would get it, because Bob's explanation is so true to Menger's insight about subjective value.

siggy47

what Menger is referring to is the natural money that emerges in a community, like in Szabo's Shelling Out

I was basically taking your question as whether or not Menger would understand Bob's point, given that Bitcoin has seemingly established itself, or if he would be skeptical of it because of how it originated.

libertarian

What Would Carl Menger Think Of Bitcoin?

> what Menger is referring to is the natural money that emerges in a community, like in Szabo's Shelling Out

I have no doubt about that. 

I was basically taking your question as whether or not Menger would understand Bob's point, given that Bitcoin has seemingly established itself, or if he would be skeptical of it because of how it originated.