Haven't had a chance to watch the series yet, but the books are fantastic. Not shocked that some of the scenes are pissing off a government that's generally more successful than most at burying history.
pull down to refresh
21 sats \ 1 reply \ @SwearyDoctor 22 Mar 2024
the books are fantastic, and there already exists a (great) Chinese series that's very close to the books which, also, are not pissing off China. SciFi is huge, and a critical attitude toward the cultural revolution is common and ok in China.
The criticism has nothing to do with that. As the article states, one of the main criticisms is that the main story and cast are now set in London. The Chinese story is ths converted into a Western one.
Also, the new series mixes and matches different parts from different books, is no longer close to the book storyline, and stumbles the deeper philosophical line of the books while horribly overdramatizing the reactions, as Hollywood does (blood-writing on the wall, gouged out eyes). All the while, the basic question - what happens when the very basis of your belief system no longer works? is just in this overdone drama and nothing else.
Also, the Chinese books are a lot more subtle about the Trisolarans. Yes, they come to "use" earth as their backup planet, fleeing the destruction of their world; but there's not as much value-judgment in that. the Hollwood version just black-and-whites this is "evil invaders", as hollywood does.
Really, go watch the Chinese "Three body", it's widely available with subtitles. it's an excellent show.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @StillStackinAfterAllTheseYears OP 22 Mar 2024
That was only a part of it:
I've read the books, and yes, it's definitely less black and white (books generally are, just given the different media). I plan on watching both miniseries.
reply
21 sats \ 0 replies \ @south_korea_ln 22 Mar 2024
Sounds like a great recommendation. Thanks
reply