I recently had an exchange on social media where I was challenged to introspect my difficulties with getting distracted by too many interests and not following through on projects by reading some stoic philosophy. I'm not a stranger to Stoic ideas, but I haven't actually sat down and read the material directly, yet.
Lately, I've been spending more attention with Buddhism and Eastern ideas, but perhaps it's time to balance that with a healthy does of Western thought. Reading some Stoicism for myself may also hopefully encourage more decisive action in my life.
So... is anybody here interested in participating in an experimental online book club? My initial thought would be to try this out reading Meditations, by Marcus Aurelius, but open to other suggestions. We'll decide on a translation, set some timeline goals for reading, and share our reflections either here on StackerNews, or on Nostr. If interested, add a comment with:
- Hell yes, confirming interest
- If you have a recommendation of translation or specific interest in a book other than Meditations
- If you prefer StackerNews or Nostr as a means for periodic communication
- Any preferences with regard to timeline
LMK - I'm interested to see where this experiment might go!
@siggy47
@cryotosensei
@carlosfandango
Welp. My copy just arrived in the mail, and I've been brainstorming about organizing principles to facilitate us learning from each other and stay engaged. Here are a few thoughts:
Since there are multiple translations, it might be helpful to share quotes liberally, especially when context or wording might be important.
Perhaps each person reads and writes at their own pace. Each chapter could be a separate post, and the first person to write up their initial reaction can take the initiative to author it. Primary discussion on that chapter would take place on that participant's post in the comment section.
I imagine all the users who have openly expressed interest in being a part of the project should be tagged in the post body, and that list might grow over time if new people join. Also, maybe we keep an index of these posts here by adding a comment thread here which links to each new post.
We share whatever we want -- anything from purely interpretive analysis on the text to deeply personal reflections on how you relate to it in your own life. Whatever we feel comfortable with.
What do you all think? Personally, I hope to read Chapter 1 sometime early next week.
Cool. Just to be sure by ‘Chapter’ do you mean ‘Book’? Not sure how your copy is divided up..?
You're right. "Book" it is.
Great!
Sounds good. I agree that chapter posts will be best, so that we can consolidate all the discussion related to a chapter in one post.
I would suggest no more than 3 chapter posts in one week, regardless of how fast we are reading. Keeps the discussion focused
Let’s roll
Great! The podcast looks good too... I'm going to try and stay away from interpretive content on the subject beforehand though, so I can see what comes up for me organically.
Happy you're interested. Let's see if there are others.
I'm pretty sure there are a bunch of stoics lurking around SN.
FYI - I've got Meditations: A New Translation on the way from Amazon, translated by Gregory Hays.
Are you still down if it's just the two of us to start?
If you build it they will come….
Am I being too optimistic to say that makes three?
Optimistic as to whether I have anything to offer..
You took the words right out of my mouth. I'm interested in learning. I hope someone knows what they're talking about.
Well we have a Chinese saying that goes something like “ three ignorant cobblers add up to a genius”. I’m sure our collective wisdom will lead to something beautiful 😍
Yes.
Hey guys, I've just been made aware of this post by @cryotosensei and I'm also down for this.
However, with my poor health at the wheel expect more of a freewheeling Bob Dylan than a pole position Lewis Hamilton.
Marcus, as a stoic obviously was seen to persevere:
So I'll give the journey a go and pick up my tablet too.
I'm down for the book and author.
Thankfully, as bitcoiners, we're reading the author with his Stoic hat and not his hat as emperor.[2]
BTW is there a link to the discussion?
https://wikiless.org/wiki/Marcus_Aurelius?lang=en ↩
According to Wikipedia Marcus, as Emperor, chose to devalue the Roman currency. If he had a tablet, surely he could have run Bitcoin? /s ↩
Discussion post is up, in case you aren’t aware
I’m sure you will have plenty of things to say, even if you regard yourself as a freewheeling Bob Dylan
Speedy recovery!
@Bitman Great! Happy to have you contribute in any capacity. I just finished reading Book 1 right now and am in the process of reflecting and compiling my thoughts. What I didn't plan for, was a massive, fascinating introduction to the book which has me a little slow to get going.
I hope to get a post for Book 1 up today, if someone doesn't beat me to it.
hell yes
I’m in. I just borrowed this from the electronic library in my country. After @Se7enZ expounded so much on the benefits of meditation, I figured I should take it as a sign from the Universe to learn more about it
https://m.stacker.news/15561
Ha! Glad to have you! This initiative is the result of wondering whether I've been doing a little too much silent sitting and trying to cultivate some more activity and accomplishment in the world... So yeah, I'm sure we have a lot to learn from each other :)
Discussion Index PostDiscussion Index Post
2/26/2023: Stoic Book Club: Meditations by Marcus Aurelius #3 - In Carnuntum
deleted by author
Somebody suggested I read Meditations to be cultivate more motivation. Feel free to chime in. Are you signalling that you want to be mentioned on future posts to stay up to date?
deleted by author