pull down to refresh
446 sats \ 3 replies \ @elvismercury 23 Dec 2023 \ parent \ on: @ delete posts...not a fan meta
I'm not against targeted deletions when a person makes a mistake, or says too much, or even just behaves in a way they later regret. That's part of being human. I'm against the generic deletation-as-a-course-of-action policy that some are demonstrating here.
When you publish something online, it's out. The UTXO of that utterance is spent and the key is exposed. I could write a bot in a few days that scrapes everything that appears on SN. Any adversary who cares enough about you to be digging through your words will have that info and they will have it whether or not you delete the post in a day.
This is why I call it LARPing -- believing you're safe because you're deleting everything is a fiction. If it's giving you a sense of security, you're fooling yourself. I'm not trying to be mean (@nemo) and I'm sorry you took it that way, but the only way to have the total safety some of you seem to want is to say nothing. That would be a loss for us and for you; but this current behavior isn't protecting you and it's bad for SN.
I'm against the generic deletation-as-a-course-of-action policy that some are demonstrating here.
I don't see this to be much of a problem right now. I can count the nyms that I am aware of that regularly delete their comments on less than two fingers. How many fingers do you need?
However, it could become a problem, yes, but I don't think it will be. If there are enough people who value evergreen content, these people will create that evergreen content themselves. As some say: "Be the change you want to see in the world"
I could write a bot in a few days that scrapes everything that appears on SN.
You could. But would you? And how would you feel about it?
Any adversary who cares enough about you to be digging through your words will have that info and they will have it whether or not you delete the post in a day.
That's part of threat modeling. Deleting comments now saves you from such a serious threat actor in the future. When something like this becomes your threat model, your past will not be as much of a vulnerability.
This is why I call it LARPing -- believing you're safe because you're deleting everything is a fiction. If it's giving you a sense of security, you're fooling yourself.
I don't think people who delete their comments believe they're safe from everything. I think they believe they are safe against their current threat model. I think they are pretty aware of what kind of level of security they gain or lose by deleting / not deleting comments.
the only way to have the total safety some of you seem to want is to say nothing.
I agree. But I guess sometimes, you are willing to sacrifice a little abstract safety for some fun if it's worth it :)
reply
This is a really thoughtful reply. A bunch of rapid-fire responses are occurring to me, but when I get this feeling it makes me alert to arguing because I'm trying to win vs arguing because I'm trying to find the truth. So I mostly won't.
You could. But would you?
No.
As some say: "Be the change you want to see in the world"
I'm trying. But not hard enough, so it's good to be reminded.
But I guess sometimes, you are willing to sacrifice a little safety for some fun if it's worth it :)
The human condition in one sentence.
I'm glad this discussion (and the other one) exist and the points that are made have been made. It will be useful as part of the ongoing public dialogue about this topic, which is bigger than SN, I think.
reply
deleted by author
reply