589 sats \ 11 replies \ @antic 2 Dec 2023 \ parent \ on: Btc privacy tradeoffs, overt and covert bitcoin
Ah, you mean the labeled UTXOs being the ruin of it. I think that will ultimately wash out. The government blacklisted Silk Road BTC, but then what? They confiscate and sell it to the market and remove the blacklisting because they washed it. The purpose of government blacklisting UTXOs is so they can catch people (and then steal the asset to sell it).
But, in the meantime, if you are operating on the dark market for UTXOs, you could get stuck holding that pre-government-cleansed blacklist UTXO.
My point is more basic. Bitcoin is money. Gold served as money for centuries. Part of the reason gold was good money was that it was fungible. If a government attempted to restrict a particular gold coin, the owner of that coin could just melt the coin into an unrecognizable lump that would be the same weight and value. That's fungibility. If we surrender that in bitcoin we are surrendering an important trait of good money. No government should have the ability to favor one type of the asset from another.
reply
Bitcoin is money.
Exactly. Nothing else. People always forget that.
reply
I talk and talk, and think about things from different angles, and then I just wind up agreeing with you. I should save time and energy.
reply
I’m not concerned about government or individual preferences because systems like Lightning exist to bypass preference.
For gold, people and governments absolutely have preferences and exercise them. That’s why American eagles have a premium over Canadian maples (even though Canadian maples have higher gold purity). Assaying gold is a nightmare and most people won’t trust a gold bar from China. Gold is barely fungible in practical terms.
Likewise, I may have a preference for $2 USD bills or classic Eisenhower dollar coins. Just because I have this preference doesn’t really mean that dollars are less fungible, just that I’ve put a premium on some forms of it.
This is inevitable to any asset that is not 100% obfuscated like monero, but I don’t think the value proposition of removing this ability to have format/source preferences is worth the trade-offs of a purely anonymous monetary system.
And, even anonymous systems like monero can be subject to preference overrides. A government could say that the only legal monero is accompanied by a Keybase.io signature linking your identity to the transaction…
reply
And, even anonymous systems like monero can be subject to preference overrides. A government could say that the only legal monero is accompanied by a Keybase.io signature linking your identity to the transaction…
That's why white market crypto usage makes little sense. Using a permissionless money (Bitcoin/Monero/etc) in a permissioned way defeats the entire purpose. And regulations/requirements on the white market are pretty much garunteed to become more onerous over time.
Bitcoin/Monero is inherently black market money.
reply
It's not an issue of preference. American Eagles and Maple Leafs are coins. You pay a premium for design- if they look pretty. The ugliest looking once ounce Krugerrand and a beautiful Eagle are the same value when melted down. You're discussing jewelry premium.
reply
They are physically not the same when melted down. The melt value of an American eagle is lower than the melt value of a maple because eagles are watered down (American Eagles contain 91.67% gold, 3% silver, and 5.33% copper, whereas a Canadian maple is 99.99% pure gold)—and yet somehow the manipulated gold market values the eagles higher.
Beauty is an arbitrary construct. My point is that anyone can think anything is more desirable and that can’t be fixed even with anonymous assets.
reply
I assume that the difference has something to do with increased confidence in the provenance of the thing, or the enthusiasm with which counterfeits are pursued, etc.
reply
An ounce of gold = an ounce of gold, like 1 btc = 1 btc. That's the real money calculation.
reply
I’d say that an ounce of gold is one ounce of gold minus assay and storage fees, but sure :)
reply
If we keep this up I'm going to download a wasabi wallet. I had better take a breath!
reply