I've read in many places that LN is not recommended for long term Bitcoin storage. Why?
Thank you for all who would write their thoughts...
895 sats \ 0 replies \ @endothermicdev 31 Aug 2023
Lightning network wallets are "hot" - the nodes are always online by design. This is what allows routing payments across nodes to occur.
If your wallet uses a private channel with a LSP (lightning service provider), you might just have an app on your phone, but you still have funds locked in a time locked contract with your peer. At any point they can try to close the channel, and could theoretically try to cheat you by broadcasting an old channel state (say the funds were all on their side of the channel at the beginning, but you've gradually accumulated funds on your side over time - they could try to broadcast the original state instead of the current balances.) Because of this, your wallet needs to be online regularly to make sure this doesn't occur. (Or use a watchtower to check for attempts to cheat you on your behalf.)
If you're using a custodial lightning wallet, it can manage channels without you, but it's obviously not a trustless way to store funds long-term - the custodian could simply shut down and run off with your funds at any time.
If you keep your node up to date and connected, you're generally okay, but there have been exploitable vulnerabilities in the past, so being able to patch your node software quickly is recommended, and operating one is not without risk.
Contrast this with offline cold storage - a hardware wallet or simply an offline seed phrase / codex32, and there is much less to go wrong for long term storage.
reply
898 sats \ 0 replies \ @theinstagibbs 31 Aug 2023
It's a very complex hot wallet. Lots of potential ways to lose your funds under adversarial or even accidental conditions.
Those risks may go down over time but it's still a hot wallet in the end.
reply
648 sats \ 0 replies \ @mallardshead 31 Aug 2023
Right now it's a transactonal layer for smaller amounts and is mostly custodial unless you run your own node/channels. Store as much longterm as you would cash in your leather wallet. Be patient, it's all being addressed.
reply
625 sats \ 0 replies \ @birdeye21 31 Aug 2023
LN is cash in the pocket
Cold storage is the bank vault
Store and spend accordingly
reply
10 sats \ 0 replies \ @TheBTCManual 31 Aug 2023
Do you keep all your savings in the wallet you keep in your pocket?
reply