pull down to refresh

At Crane Stationery, the craft of high-precision engraving is in danger of becoming lost artAt Crane Stationery, the craft of high-precision engraving is in danger of becoming lost art

Master engravers have etched the custom designs and lettering on Crane Stationery since the days of Paul Revere—who, according to company lore, was one of its first customers.
Today, with just a dozen left and at least one set to retire this year, these tradespeople are disappearing. Artificial intelligence and automation aren’t the reason. It is because it is so hard to entice humans to learn the highly skilled precision craft.

Oh look, another article about the skilled trades, which are probably AI-proof at least for the near future.

...

Pay is another challenge. Unable to be replicated by machines, these kinds of highly human-precision skills are increasingly sought after. Yet wages haven’t caught up. New apprentices start at $18.50 an hour. With quarterly bonuses, a new engraver who has graduated from an apprenticeship can make up to $60,000 a year.

Oh.

To be honest, I feel a bit bait and switched by these articles. The headline is always, "Hey look, skilled trades are a viable alternative in the age of AI!" But then the text of the article shows that these jobs are not very attractive after all. As @Undisciplined said, "It's almost like there aren't any free lunches lying around." (Or some such)

21 sats \ 0 replies \ @anon 2h
reply
these kinds of highly human-precision skills are increasingly sought after. Yet wages haven’t caught up.

The author didn't notice the inconsistency of these two statements?

In what sense are they being sought after, if not through higher wage offerings?

reply

There is possibly a lag? If they can't fill positions at the current wage then the wage pressure would be upwards. If the marginal revenue product can't sustain a higher wage, then I suppose the whole industry is in for a contraction.

reply

"Increasingly sought after" sounds like a rightward demand shift to me. We're being told the supply shift is to the left.

Saying the price hasn't caught up makes me think they're confusing vacancies with shortages, which is basically what you were saying. Demand actually shifted inwards along with supply and we'll have fewer of these jobs.

reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @xz 11h

and who seeks for a job in a dying industry?

I think there's some truth in your point, but also some inconsistency in the original statement.

reply

Ford CEO Jim Farley recently stated that approximately 5,000 mechanic positions remain vacant at Ford dealerships across the U.S., with many offering salaries around $120,000 to $160,000.

view on www.youtube.com
reply

I posted about this too: #1406466

Those salary numbers are pretty misleading.

reply

WSJ is also misleading, they barely have any credibility left

Writers are subpar and woke

p.s. you read the wrong article, https://www.wsj.com/lifestyle/careers/why-ford-cant-fill-this-six-figure-job-30e86f81

reply