Dan Wang explores how the United States and China, while rivals in power, share surprising similarities that shape their economies, politics, and global influence.The title of Dan Wang’s book Breakneck focuses on the People’s Republic of China (PRC) specifically, but it is really about the self-conscious great-power rivalry between China’s Communist Party leaders and the United States. Along the way, we encounter all the popular points of controversy between the two great nations, covering everything from bullet trains, iPhone factories, and Trump tariffs to zero-COVID lockdowns, rare-earth mineral supply chains, and the demographic long tail of the One Child policy.This isn’t just another case of two big nations clashing—as big nations tend to do from time to time. For finance analyst and university research fellow Dan Wang, the US and the PRC are uniquely paired in world affairs. In his introduction, he writes, “…no two peoples are more alike than Americans and Chinese,” citing their shared love of consumerism, pragmatic natures, and appreciation for technological progress.Wang sees the US and PRC economies, in particular, as complements, which explains the rapid growth of trade between the two in the twenty-first century: “It is almost uncanny how much the United States and China have been complementary of each other.”Yet at the same time, he says that, on a political level, “the two systems are a study in contrasts.” Fair enough, as they’re obviously very different. Yet in other passages, he frames the US and PRC systems as “inversions” of each other. This is seen in each society’s attitudes toward innovation and technology adoption, and to politics in general. It would take a sublime Confucian scholar to disentangle these contradictions. Perhaps the two nations are the phoenix and the dragon of world politics, the cobra and the mongoose, or simply each other’s evil twin.
pull down to refresh
related posts
100 sats \ 4 replies \ @Undisciplined 19h
This rings very true.
When I was on a trip to China, the similarities really stood out. In some ways it was like America cranked to 11.
Many Chinese people I’ve talked to also noticed the similarities. In particular noting how well Chinese and American people get along when we both tend to rub other peoples the wrong way.
reply
69 sats \ 1 reply \ @SimpleStacker 18h
Chinese tourists have a bad rep for being rude, kinda like American tourists. I wonder if there is something about being a world power that makes you more rude in other countries.
One major difference I've observed is that the Chinese respect personal space and queuing less than Americans. A Chinese person is much more likely to stand right next to you, like shoulder to shoulder, than an American is. Chinese people, by my observation, are also more likely to cut in line.
reply
67 sats \ 0 replies \ @Undisciplined 18h
Yes, those were probably the two biggest differences.
In fact, I still can’t wrap my head around their queuing norms. People do stand in lines while others are mobbing through and they don’t seem upset about the situation.
Being there actually completely changed my mind about one of our norms. Chinese people don’t wait for people who are taking pictures in public. They just walk right through and I think they’re right to do so. If you want to take up a bunch of public space for a picture, you should be the one who waits for the crowd to clear.
reply
69 sats \ 1 reply \ @0xbitcoiner OP 19h
You notice any similarities in the rural areas as well?
reply
50 sats \ 0 replies \ @Undisciplined 18h
We didn’t get to spend much time in rural areas. We just passed through on our way to the next big city.
The population density is so much greater than in America that I didn’t see much that even resembled our rural communities. I think you’d have to go further west than we did to see that.
reply