pull down to refresh
0 sats \ 14 replies \ @OT 16h \ on: China Hardens Military Stance Against U.S. With Nuclear Weapons and Tough Talk econ
You seem to be quite the China bull. Just wondering if you have an answer as to why the wealthy and the talented continue to leave China?
China bull?
Just dealing with reality- are you?
Do they?
Do you have evidence that emigration from China is higher than other similar countries?
Certainly the average income on China is still lower than most western nations but pay rates in nearly all sectors of China are rising far more quickly than in the west.
With Chinas undeniable economic development it is natural and unavoidable that a lot of Chinese do move to work in other countries as opportunities expand but a lot of that is part of Chinas expanding importance in the global economy.
A lot of Chinese also travel abroad to work and train and gain skills as do people from most developed economies- this is normal and advantageous to those with the aptitude and wealth to do this and ultimately benefits both individuals and economies of China and other nations. Look at the engineering and scientific faculties of many western universities and many of the faces are now Chinese. Chinese value skills and wealth accumulation just like all people do- perhaps more so!
A lot of Chinas economic growth is based upon gaining scientific and commercial expertise from global sources and experience.
There are far more millionaires and billionaires created every day in China than in the US.
I am curious why so many Libertarians struggle to understand that the Chinese economy is growing at a rate far exceeding the US.
Is it because you have an irrational belief that a pure free market generates superior wealth than a mixed economy?
Even though the US economy is far from a free market and is now imposing unprecedented levels of trade obstruction across the board on trading partners.
US wealth is hugely reliant upon its exceptional privilege of being the reserve currency issuer but that privilege looks increasingly fragile as demand for USTs declines rapidly.
Do you struggle with accepting that the US is losing its global dominance and the wealth and power that derived from that?
reply
Have you ever been to China? I lived in China for 15 years so I think I have more of an insight than westerners following the China news. The main one is that reporting often augments the image of what's actually happening.
BTW, I don't know how this all plays out, I'm just watching it from the sidelines. I just find it interesting how you keep repeating that China has won. I wouldn't be too confident if I were you.
reply
It is clear that China has won the trade war- it is already dominant in global trade and supply chains as Trump has realised belatedly how dependent the US is on Chinese supply chains- the Chinese can and are calling the shots- if Trump wants the rare earths essential to US military and manufacturing.
China has enjoyed incredible economic growth and is now challenging US hegemony.
Stating these facts seems to get a lot of people very defensive...but I do not see how it is untrue or exaggerated as many more informed authorities than me are now also saying much the same thing. The previous US ambassador to the US for example.
#1224678
And the above article this post is based on that reports Chinas growing military power and confidence.
Have you read that article?
Or the one about Ambassador Burns and his concerns?
Would be interesting to hear what facts, opinions and judgements you have based on the 15 years you claim to have lived in China but am also more concerned with credible and verifiable news sources than anecdotes and unverifiable, unsourced opinions.
Naturally this whole topic is very difficult for Libertarians and US exceptionalists who struggle to even believe China and the CCP could be a real threat to the extraordinary privilege and wealth that the US has come to expect and depend upon.
Because it highlights US hypocrisy and imperialism and because it shatters many of the myths and delusions that have grown up around the US and its wealth, power and privilege.
I am personally no more in favour of Chinese hegemony than US hegemony ~ having lived mostly in the west and its culture I am more comfortable in western culture than Chinese, but rather believe that all manifestations of power tend to corrupt and absolute power, even more so.
I also believe, given the almost universal denial of these issues by participants on Stacker News that there is a significant amount of denial around this issue and that denial in term is a real threat to the security of the west. Its like people cannot see whats happening and these reports I have highlighted from well informed experts including the two linked above reinforce this apprehension.
Please feel free to respond and assuage my concerns for the security of western civilisation with something more credible than off hand flippant denial that there is a problem when the quoted sources above say there is a very real and imminent danger!
BTW Your graph showing millionaire migration shows most leave from the US, followed by China- China today daily produces more millionaires than the US yet still a lot more flee the US- probably due to the increasing instability in the US and taxes...and the attractive allure of places like the UAE with their low taxes.
reply
You might want to spend some time there to get a better insight. Maybe its related to culture but they seem to value the appearance of something over quality or substance. I'll give you a few examples. There was an Italian restaurant where they hired a European to dress like a chef to greet guests and give the customers the impression that it was a genuine Italian restaurant. What I found is that this kind of stuff happens not only on a micro level but also on a macro. When there is a slum of old housing they build a nice looking wall to block its sight.
Now of course the military is a different animal and it's true that everything is still all made in China. I just would take what I read about China with a grain of salt.
reply
I am well aware of the Chinese and Asian culture of 'face'.
That cultural difference to the west, is as you must be aware if you did spend more than a decade in China, just one of many significant differences in the Chinese world view which can lead to misunderstanding and error on the part of westerners looking at China.
I traded extensively with Chinese merchants and businesses for over a decade and learned some of the differences in culture which it seems very few westerners understand.
But none of these differences lessen the potential threat China poses- quite the opposite- they often obscure and cloud the view mist in the west have of China to one of ignorance, misunderstanding and fear.
The Yellow Peril hysteria of more than a century ago is just one example.
And certainly the culture of 'face' extends to Chinese media coverage and portrayal- but I rely almost entirely upon the views and reports of western media and westerners who have experience in China such as those I have given above already.
Another excellent source I would refer to is Peter Hesslers books on China written during his time living there from the mid 1990s until the mid 2000s. Though now maybe a little dated they do nothing to refute my thesis.
In fact since Hessler left China and Xi rose to power the direction of Chinas advance has become significantly more aggressive, overt and direct as a challenge to the west.
I have already provided several up to date and contemporary warnings - from people who have lived in China and who have verifiable credentials and who are warning us of what they see as a credible and real threat and challenge coming from China today...you have refuted nothing of the substance what they have said...you have not even acknowledged it.
reply
reply
那你最好开始学习中文 'Then you'd better start learning Chinese.'
Just the sort of flippant Trumpian answer I have come to expect.
Typical of the inability to acknowledge and respond to this issue in a reasonable considered way that exercises the constructive potential of freedom of speech and contest of ideas.
Instead of acknowledging the facts and issues raised you avoid them via parody.
You thereby concede defeat in terms of a contest of ideas, by defaulting to trollery.
Your inability to respond in a credible reasoned manner is just further evidence of the problem I have raised.
Again you do exactly what a CCP Bot might logically be expected to do - to disrupt any attempt to discuss and raise awareness of these issues.
reply
Nah man you're just repetitive.
Lol, it's not like you ever post any solutions to what you believe. The reason I personally don't make bold claims is because I honestly don't know how this is going to play out. There are too many moving parts in fields that I know little about. So best to be humble and do what I can.