pull down to refresh
I've never thought much about what CJ's ceiling might have been.
How do 8 All-Defense teams, with 4 DPOY's and 4 All NBA selections compare with that?
I realize you said "offensive" stat, but it's not like CJ gets subbed out on defense.
Do you agree with me that Oladipo had a higher peak than CJ?
I think I like to choose according to career instead of ceiling / peak. If I'm a GM drafting a player, I would take someone who can give me multiple seasons with consistent performance over someone who just peak for a season then goes on being hurt the rest of their career.
That's fair. I'm just curious if you think CJ was the better player throughout.
Probably not from pure talent wise. Oladipo is much more athletic and better defensively, while both probably gave similar offensive numbers. It's just that CJ had such a better career and Oladipo was hurt so much that it's hard for me to pick him over CJ while knowing how their careers played out.
Maybe because I never really liked Rudy that much, so that's why I put him behind CJ. A lot of subjectivity involved in these picks anyways. But I see your point and understand why you would put Rudy at second.