pull down to refresh

@BitcoinErrorLog had a low-drama take on X:

Play is always warning apps about upcoming requirements. There are none for our wallet app tha are related to this.

Has any wallet anywhere reported having to get a license?

I think this is just sloppy FAQ web content.

Also Jungle Francis:

Literally none of them would be able to comply (even if they wanted to, which is outrageous). This is effectively a Google ban on self-custody. My hunch is that it will get reversed or amended because it's so outright insane, and I don't rule out it having been a comms mistake.

JC is correct on this? Xitter reporting Google clarifying to JD that the rumours are not correct

reply

Right you are:

Thanks for flagging this. Non-custodial wallets are not in scope of Google Play’s Cryptocurrency Exchanges and Software Wallets Policy. We are updating the Help Center to make this clear.
view on x.com
reply

Most likely this was a trial balloon to test public response. If we hadn't raised hell immediately good chance it would go through.

As it is, this is extremely bad anyway: it'll still ban lots of useful wallets, including cashu wallets, LN wallets that use tech like cash to build up enough of a balance to open a channel, etc. etc. Even Zeus won't be allowed: they recently added cashu support.

reply

Wait why is cashu targeted by this if it's not self-custodial?

reply

Ecash mints are custodial. They are like banks that give you bank notes that allow you to redeem your money from the bank in the future.

reply

So this information is... not correct?
So non-custodial wallets on Google Play, in the US and EU aren't restricted???

reply

Looks that way, the rage have updated their view lol

reply

hey fuck that guy and his takes

reply

And then there's this take by @petertodd:

You are incredibly naive if you think APKs are a reliable solution to get around this.

Without political opposition, side-loading will be banned. It already isn't possible on iOS.

"Cypherpunks write code" is B.S. The real cypherpunks wrote PGP. Then sued the US govt and won.
reply