pull down to refresh

Interesting.
If i'm understanding correctly, his claim is that the quantum factorization algorithms have only been demonstrated on toy cases that were specifically engineered to be doable in a lab, but haven't been demonstrated to work on general cases where the researcher isn't able to control the inputs, nor knows the correct answer of the output.
Is that right?
Yep, that is my understanding as well as Steve Gibson's summary. His paper is pretty narrowly focused on that and honestly its interesting to read people's responses that haven't read the paper but seem to acknowledge he is correct even if reluctantly.
reply