This is always a problem with users who don’t pay attention and think that custodial wallets are meant for long-term storage.

Back in 2023, BlueWallet shut down its public Lightning node because they saw a large increase in usage, most likely due to Nostr zapping. They posted some messages on their blog and social media but didn’t have a way to contact any of their users directly. To this day I still run into people who gave up on Lightning because they had sats on BlueWallet that they lost, and they assumed Lightning itself didn’t work.

If you have money stored on a website, or in an app, and you don’t have the keys, you should assume it’s just an IOU. It’s not anyone’s responsibility but yours to take ownership. It wasn’t stolen from you. You abandoned it.

One of the worst articles I’ve seen about bitcoin in a while – instant classic!

What are you doing to address the speed of swaps? In real-world testing I've seen a Lightning <> Liquid swap take around 30 seconds, in some cases longer. This is a major friction point for retail. Tap-to-pay customers and merchants are expecting a near-instant payment confirmation, and when they have to sit there awkwardly waiting for a payment to be accepted, it can cause anxiety and disillusionment.

Hi Kilian! Thanks for hosting this AMA.

My first question is about centralization. Now that a lot of new products have been released that rely on Boltz for their basic functionality, it raises concerns of there being a single point of failure should these swap services become temporarily or permanently unavailable, or outright banned in certain jurisdictions. What's being done to decrease that type of risk?

Looks like a joke.

PayPal is a hotbed of fraud. I’ve never used HodlHodl but I once had a client claw back funds on a freelance job after paying me with PayPal and I’ll never use it again.

Our operations staff has been running the numbers and streamlined the menu. It wasn’t one of our best sellers. We’ve been getting creative and offering more specials. If there’s enough demand we could bring it back as a limited-time offer, kind of like the McRib.

Sadly, that's no longer on the menu.

Eating challenges seem so fiat.

Is there even really a better place?

I know, right?

We’ll be open at our normal time of 1 PM on Saturday 4/20 with some half-priced bitcoin-only specials starting at 4:20 PM.

Feel free to camp out on the sidewalk in front of the bar. Some people do that all the time.

Short answer is this is always top of mind as a business, especially one with a kitchen and bar, and that’s before you even think about the bitcoin stuff.

Need Thomas to take this one in more depth, but he just left to catch a flight so he might not see this for a while.

LOL

Thank you!

Before PubKey existed, there was another dive bar in this location called Formerly Crow's, and before that it was The Stoned Crow. Thomas used to run bitcoin meetups at what was then his neighborhood bar, somewhat embarrassingly called "Crypto at the Crow." When the pub closed down, Thomas and the other cofounders (Andrew and Jerk) partnered with the previous owner Marshall to reopen the bar as PubKey in 2022 after the NYC bitcoin scene (and the city at large) took a major hit during two years of Covid. Apart from BitDevs and other local meetups including Harlem Bitcoin, there wasn't much out there in the way of a purely bitcoin-focused gathering place. One of the best things about it is that it's still a neighborhood dive bar, and many people who come here don't even realize it's a bitcoin bar at first, because a lot of the bitcoin content fades into the background aesthetic and it's waiting to be discovered by those who look for it. Probably 60-70% of our regular customers are pre-coiners.

We also don't see SN as competition at all, because we're a physical space where people connect in the real world, something that even the best digital platforms can't reproduce.

It can be hard to explain how Lightning works to someone who is new to bitcoin, because it requires a basic understanding of how payment channels and UTXOs work. Customers who come from out-of-state with apps like Strike (not available in New York) have an easier time making Lightning payments, because they are getting something that's more of a Venmo-like experience.

To set up your own self-custodial Lightning wallet on something like Zeus or Phoenix, you have to have some bitcoin on-chain that you can use to open a channel. People get confused why they have to make an initial transaction to send or receive sats on Lightning. This is also why we host monthly Lightning meetups, because there is a lot of education to be done.

As much as people from New York like to crap on New Jersey, they don't have the BitLicense there. If we opened a bar a mile and a half west of our location in Jersey City, we could do a lot more bitcoin stuff.

It's pretty hard to get people to part with their sats even for deep discounts. Once the novelty of paying in bitcoin wears off, people usually go back to fiat so they can stack more.

jinx

Depends on what it's worth but you wouldn't get any change back.

They're as regular as it gets.