Which “Dune” do you like better and why? \ stacker news ~movies

pull down to refresh

Which “Dune” do you like better and why?

624 sats \ 43 comments \ @Rothbardian_fanatic 11 Dec movies

There were several movie versions of Dune one in the ‘80s one in the ‘90s and one in the ‘20s. Each one shows a different and unique perspective on the book, tuned to the times in which it was made. Which one did you like best and why did you like it best?

David Lynch — Dune19.2%

Sci-fi channel “Frank Herbert’s “Dune’”11.5%

Denis Villeneuve‘s two part “Dune”69.2%

26 votes \ poll ended

view all related items

40 sats \ 3 replies \ @IamSINGLE 11 Dec

I gotta watch them now. I didn't think they were so popular.

21 sats \ 2 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

The latest pair were very popular in the theaters. Many of us saw them more than once on the big screen. BTW, the big screen is the best way to see them.

40 sats \ 1 reply \ @IamSINGLE 11 Dec

You know I'm from India and we only occassionally watch hollywood movies. However I've seen the promos for Dune on OTTs here. I'll watch them today or tomorrow.

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Good luck with them. See them any way you can. The music is special, too.

31 sats \ 3 replies \ @DesertDave 11 Dec

Th newer ones are some of my favorite newer movies. I really liked them a lot.

63 sats \ 2 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

I haven’t seen any other new ones at the theater, but these. I think that these are best seen with a huge screen, not the little digital screens.

21 sats \ 1 reply \ @BeeAye 11 Dec

yes, major big screen energy movies

11 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

The music also requires it.

40 sats \ 3 replies \ @yoshi 11 Dec

Has anyone watched the new TV series? Worth watching?

41 sats \ 1 reply \ @DarthCoin 11 Dec

Yes I am watching it. Is really interesting and the action just started. Is worth watching it.

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Great! A good review! Where can I see it?

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Haven’t seen it, but heard a little about it, very little. No opinion on worthiness.

60 sats \ 5 replies \ @Aardvark 11 Dec

I really liked the OG and the movies. It's a tough call, but i picked the movies.

21 sats \ 4 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Why did you enjoy the latest movies? What did you enjoy about them more than the others?

60 sats \ 3 replies \ @Aardvark 11 Dec

So in the OG it does a lot of exposition throughout the movie, and then towards the end they sort of gloss over stuff at the end that was in the book. It was still really good.

In the movies I like that it was slowed down because it was two movies. I loved how they leaned into the religious aspect of the story and the cinematography was fantastic. The music was great also, I'm a big Hanz Zimmer fan.

20 sats \ 1 reply \ @nichro 11 Dec

Hans Zimmer was the first movie composer name I learned to recognize.

Never cared about credits, but sometimes the music was so banger I'd be like who is this??

And every time it was Hans Fking Zimmer

I don't think the music in Dune is the most memorable compared to some other scores, but this is not meant as a criticism.

The music works in Dune. I say "work" here not merely as in "fits" but as in it had a straight up job and it involved some heavy lifting and it broke a sweat and got it done and should probably get a raise and a promotion.

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

I liked it since I identified it in Interstellar and Inception. When the music seems special, I always look to see the composer, even if I have to wait through a whole lot of scrolling credits.

11 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

I’ve got to agree on the Hans Zimmer music!! They couldn’t have gotten anyone better for the movies, being that the books are so famous and well liked. I think they were all good, each from a different perspective. Different writers (adapters) and different directors.

40 sats \ 1 reply \ @Satosora 11 Dec

For anyone that wants to watch the David Lynch Spicediver fan edit, here it is: https://archive.org/details/dune-1984-alternative-edition-redux-fanedit-mkv-flac-subs/Dune+(1984)+Alternative+Edition+Redux+%5Bfanedit%5D%5BMKV-FLAC-SUBS%5D/Dune+(1984)+Alternative+Edition+Redux+%5Bfanedit%5D%5BMKV-FLAC-SUBS%5D.mkv They took out all the nonsense scenes, and made the movie many times better.

20 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Thanks for the link. I will have to watch it.

30 sats \ 3 replies \ @Shugard 11 Dec

I am a sucker for great scenery. That's why I love Lord of the Rings so much. A deep story, but man, the big scenes on screen with monumental buildings, incredible nature... I'm a sucker for that.

Thanks to modern CGI we can create monumental scenes. If the story is also deep and well written, like in the case of Dune, I go for the modern versions.

21 sats \ 2 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

You can certainly say that the vistas are wide in these movies. I don’t know it it is all CGI or on-site, looked to me like a lot of it was on-location. Deserts are tough places to be for things like movies.

20 sats \ 1 reply \ @Shugard 11 Dec

Agreed, maybe we shouldn't call it CGI, but maybe CGI enhanced locations?

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Yes, that works for me. Somehow they are inhanced.

20 sats \ 2 replies \ @softglitter2d 11 Dec

Denis Villeneuve's Dune is evolution pure and simple. It's how you build something awesome from an awesome book. I do really like the 80s version but since I have to put sats in it, that's my answer.

Is it accurate? No, it's not. Do I care? No, because Denis didn't destroy the esence of Arrakis and the characters were beautifully composed in the movie. Yes, it's not like the book¹ however, the artwork worth those little arrangements.

I'm currently reading 4/6 saga. The God-Worm is outstanding. ↩

0 sats \ 1 reply \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

My take on comparing books to movies is that a movie will never do justice to the book. It cannot because they are two different media. A book is only limited by the imagination of the reader, whereas a movie must make everything visually knowable. I have liked all versions, so far. They are each focused differently, though.

What is 4/6 saga?

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @softglitter2d 12 Dec

My bad. Frank wrote initially three books; Dune, Messiah and Children of Dune. Then three more: God Emperor, Heretics of Dune and finally Chapterhouse. Right now, I'm reading 4/6 intial saga which is God Emperor. Worth it.

20 sats \ 1 reply \ @Roll 11 Dec

You can not compare all of 3, -Lynch it was in 1984 so he did what it could with the bugdet , special effects on this moment. But, it s a huge at that time . -The book it s all the best version ( it s your imagination that creates the universe) -And the last movie diferent budget, diferent special efects ...in a way it s better but diferent times...

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Yes, that was my feeling about the three movies. Different budgets, different times and different technology created much different movies, All of them had notable actors and actresses in them, all were good and all had different foci. I still liked them all.

20 sats \ 1 reply \ @WeAreAllSatoshi 11 Dec

Never seen any of them. Should I?

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

If you are a Science Fiction fan you may want to see them all! I think it is better if you read the novel first, though. The novel is so good they have made three movies of it.

20 sats \ 3 replies \ @anna 11 Dec

I love them all but Villeneuve’s is so epic and beautifully shot. I prefer the beautiful cinematography over accuracy to the books

11 sats \ 2 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

I can understand that. After all, movies are for the eyes and tell you all that is happening by visual cues. If you are a Dune fan, sometimes the inaccuracies get in the way of enjoying the movie you have in front of you.

21 sats \ 1 reply \ @anna 11 Dec

I definitely understand that. I enjoyed the books but they’re not one of my favorite series. If it is a series I really really like, inaccuracies are hard to watch

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

You must have seen the poll I did on sci-fi series then. I was wondering what series everyone here enjoyed the most.

20 sats \ 5 replies \ @Satosora 11 Dec

Even though the scifi channel was a low budget endeavor, l like this one because l watched it when it came out on the tv. I even remember recording it on tape!

20 sats \ 4 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

Yep, I waited until I could get it on DVDs and copied them all. I haven’t gotten the newest one yet, looking for the whole set.

20 sats \ 3 replies \ @Satosora 11 Dec

They made a whole series out of it. James McAvoy was perfect for the Leto role.

20 sats \ 2 replies \ @Rothbardian_fanatic OP 11 Dec

The guy they had for Paul Atreides was also fit for the part.

20 sats \ 1 reply \ @Satosora 11 Dec

He was more of a stage actor, right? Alec Newman. He made a lot of good tv shows, just never got super famous.

Footnotes