In this short article, I briefly look at the challenges facing contemporary marriages and explore how using multisig Bitcoin wallets can mitigate these issues. By aligning incentives and preventing fraud, this approach can correct the distortions caused by the welfare state. Furthermore, I briefly discuss some issues pertinent to this mechanism.
Problems:
A marriage with separation of assets means that both parties keep an exit door open, the spouses do not trust each other, and the woman will never interrupt her career to have and raise children, as she will be a slave to work for 10 hours a day.
In marriages with community property, one of the spouses can defraud the other, something called misappropriation or property violence, stealing the values that should belong to the couple, leaving the other destitute in the event of separation.
Even in a marriage with community property, spouses can hide values, when there is no trust, using asset hiding mechanisms, such as oranges.
Solution:
Multisig 2/2 bitcoin wallets serve to align incentives in a marriage, as they are non-confiscable and provide security for both parties. Funds can only be moved if both parties sign the transaction. This protects against misappropriation by either party and ensures that the funds truly belong to both parties.
This provides security for women to leave their careers and dedicate themselves to their children or domestic work, serving as collateral. The biggest risk is that neither party will withdraw the funds if there is no consensus between them.
As it becomes impossible for one spouse to defraud the other, this aligns the incentives so that both spouses will not seek to engage in adultery or fraud.
Timelock transactions guarantee inheritance in the event of the death of one of the parties, and there may be a trusted oracle that would sign a transaction in these cases.
Transactions signed but not transmitted may allow for an emergency withdrawal of funds if necessary (example: Paying the bail of one of the parties who was arrested for tax evasion).
Questions about this mechanism:
It does not replace the need for total trust between spouses, which is a fundamental pillar. In other words, on the one hand, this mechanism can bring a feeling of lack of trust.
It is not flexible if one spouse needs to have quick access to funds in an emergency situation, this could be partially resolved using signed but not transmitted transactions, allowing for an emergency withdraw in an emergency.
As a personal opinion, I would add that, in addition to multisig, it is important that each party has their own keys, outside the multisig scheme, thus avoiding 100% of the funds being frozen in this mechanism.
Conclusion
Using multisig Bitcoin wallets in a marriage offers an innovative approach to aligning incentives between spouses, providing asset security and encouraging collaboration and mutual trust. However, additional research is needed to explore the practical implications of this approach.
The specific way to implement this mechanism (whether as a 2/2, 2/3, or 2/5 configuration) and the associated operational rules are important technical details. While these may seem like minutiae, exploring these aspects in depth can be valuable in illustrating concrete examples of implementation and providing a clearer understanding of how the system might work in practice.
131 sats \ 1 reply \ @davidw 3 Mar
Novel concept but still some details to iron-out. Perhaps a multi-sig could supplant or merge with marriages, as a more convenient "commitment transaction".
Marriages often end-up with a huge cost outlay with engagement rings, ceremonies, honeymoons, anniversaries & expensive divorces to deter casual arrangements. Multi-sig ceremonies could be a much more simplistic financial arrangement in future decades. Even if the concept of marriage is aspirational and a beautiful part of life.
If this becomes mainstream, I hope for @jimmysong to be my vicar and to officiate my multi-sig ceremony 🤣
reply
It's a cool idea, but the harder part is the money earned after the marriage begins. How do you ensure that all your income goes into the 2-of-2 multisig? I suppose this is where vows come in =)
reply
I gotta say, when I started reading this, I was pretty dubious.
I can see how a 2 of 2 could align incentives. A couple has to work together to maintain access to their funds. But it sure feels like fixing the wrong problem. If a couples' funds or the way they store them are an issue, that isn't the issue.
If marriage isn't based on a commitment between two people, what even are you doing? It might be simpler just to put the time into building the relationship, instead of the multisig.
reply
I like the alignment part but my mind races with obscure scenarios like what happens if one spouse gets in a wreck & winds up in a coma? Sure it could be set to time out, but clearly a bunch of money would be immediately needed for medical bills, possibly to save that spouse's life.
I could see this working better as a savings account that was opened at the wedding. All your friends and family contribute sats instead of handing you an envelope on the big day... And throughout your marriage you both have the option to add sats to it, perhaps a little out of each paycheck, to save up for something like a dream home or vacation budget... But everyday living money stays left out, in your normal wallet.
reply
deleted by author
reply
Brilliant. The priest conducting the mariage ceremony should definitely hold a key. 😅
reply
Could you elaborate a little bit more about the "trusted oracle that would sign a transaction".
reply
This is very clever proof of concept
Two words: prenuptial contract
reply