I'm a long-time lurker on r/Bitcoin and related subreddits. I registered an account 11 months ago in order to respond to posts and comments and have made a total of 4 comments there.
This may be a bit of a long rant, but whatever. I need to get this off my chest.
So...
Two weeks ago I posted a comment to a post titled "Bitcoin stuck on blockchain, need advice", where I provided four paragraphs of analysis and advice on the situation. A few minutes later I got a message in my Reddit inbox:
u/shafemtol is permanently banned from r/BitcoinHello, You have been permanently banned from participating in r/Bitcoin because you broke this community's rules. You won't be able to post or comment, but you can still view and subscribe to it.Note from the moderators:Reddit has suspended your account. Subreddit moderators don't know why and can't help you. You will need to contact site admins directly via this link. https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360045734511
This caught me by surprise, as up until that point I had not seen any indication that my account was suspended. When logged in, everything seemed fine. But then I logged out and visited my own profile page:
This account has been suspended
And going to the various places where I've posted my comments, those comments are of course gone without a trace as soon as I log out.
According to the reddithelp article above:
Suspensions are notified via a private message. [...] Information about your suspension will be specified here.
Yet I got no such notification until r/Bitcoin permanently banned my account citing a Reddit suspension.
A visual reminder of the suspension will appear on each page you visit and any time a forbidden action is attempted. On the website and mobile apps, you will see a banner describing your ban and its duration.
Yet when logged in, I see absolutely nothing indicating a suspension.
Temporary suspensions will only be apparent to the user. Permanent suspensions will be publicly communicated via the user page and accessible by other users.
So I have been permanently suspended from Reddit, with no notification and no reason given.
An account suspension is an action taken by Reddit’s administration for security purposes or to enforce our Content Policy.
Had I broken their Content Policy? At this point, all I had discussed on Reddit was:
- The use of commas vs. dots as decimal separators
- The formula for the Bitcoin block subsity
- Whether a perfectly fair coin or casino grade dice are necessary for generating a Bitcoin seed
- How to deal with a non-confirming transaction
As far as I can see, none of these subjects are against their Content Policy. Everything on-topic, no negativity, nothing spammy, nothing scammy.
If you think a suspension for a content violation was applied incorrectly, you can submit an appeal. [...] Find your suspension message in your inbox and appeal your suspension through the unique link provided. If you don’t see a link, you can appeal your suspension through https://www.reddit.com/appeals.
So I did. But I've received zero response. I doubt my appeal was ever read, or will ever be read, by a human soul.
So...
I'm left with only one possible explanation:
I've been automatically, permanently shadowbanned from Reddit for the offense of using Tor Browser.
Using Tor Browser isn't a great user experience in general. You're too anonymous. Like you're up to no good. Probably a criminal hacker or a botnet. Every server is set up against you. Captcha this. Captcha that. Prove you're not a robot by feeding Big AI with your human labor. Please try again. Contact your network administrator. Secure Connection Failed.
Whatever. For most browsing, it's mostly an annoyance. Worst case you try a new Tor circuit, check the page on Wayback Machine, or just go somewhere else.
It hurts a bit more to realize all the things you thought you had shared with your community for the last year have silently been directed into a black hole.