Okay I have this crazy idea. I think if this is properly implemented, it can bring tremendous value to SN users and owners. It's tricky, because there are perverse incentives everywhere you look. Here goes:
A sub dedicated to product reviews. The UI will have to be a bit different, more search oriented, because recent content is not necessarily going to be more relevant. Amazon reviews used to be reliable but they've gone to shit. I literally have no idea how to find quality products online outside of niches that I'm well-familiar with. In order to prevent spam, the posting charge would have to be somewhat high, and it would be limited to people who have been on SN for a while and for whom most engagement with SN is NOT via the product review sub. In other words, only people who use SN regularly and just happened to buy a product they like and want to tell others about it. People who appreciate the review tip with sats as with other posts. This is equivalent to the "people who found this review helpful" feature in Amazon.
I think this could be very useful to a lot of people. It's so difficult to find quality information in situations where there are strong incentives to game the system.
I understand what you mean by forum style, but I don't know what you mean by "expand laterally."
We plan to do more weird subs beyond ~jobs and more weird post types beyond bounties if that's what you mean. We all want subs for buying and selling things.
Laterally meaning other than forum. ie. I still consider Reddit at its core a forum, yes there are subs for buying and selling but nothing integral to the site
I love SN because of its similarities to Reddit. Good content rises to the top.
The blackout that has been underway the last 2 days, has really highlighted the need for an alternative and surely that alternative is right here? Should SN not be allowing custom ~subjects to be made about anything and let the platform grow where users want it to grow?
I know there have been discussions around ~tech but curious why SN are limiting it.
Example of a subreddit discussion on the blackout, where they feel there is no alternative:
I don't see SN as "the alternative" to Reddit. I think Tildes fits the most to what some Redditors look for in an alternative without the images posts and NSFW, even RiF developer is working on a Tildes client.
I find SN more akin to an HN alternative, HN has been the same site since its inception?, also can't take HN seriously with its anti-Bitcoin stance.
yeah damn it.... the whole month of May was dry, but I was busy with other things.
Now the whole month of June every fucking day is raining and I can't go.
I really need to finish that citadel.