pull down to refresh

Yes60.0%
No40.0%
35 votes \ poll ended
No, cursive's dumb.
There's a paragraph about integrity, or something, on the GRE's that you're supposed to write verbatim in cursive. It was taking me so long that I decided to just call their bluff and write it normal. I had long since forgotten how to write a few letters.
Apparently that was fine.
reply
i disagree. handwriting is easier when you know cursive and there's just no denying the sophistication of a handwritten letter scratched with a fountain pen onto parchment paper and sealed with red wax bearing your family insignia.
reply
Those points all have merit and, yet, I maintain my position.
reply
well, that's your second-cousin-twice-removed-living-in-a-remote-village-in-romania's loss. (we all have one, right, and who else is there to write such letters to?)
reply
Clearly, I didn't have sufficient pen pals to retain my cursive abilities.
reply
I really enjoy writing it. I've probably written hundreds of thousands of words that way. Can't really imagine what it would be like to write without cursive.
But I'm only half-heartedly teaching my kids cursive. We've spent a lot more time on typing.
reply
If you enjoy it that much, there's a decent chance they'll want to learn as well.
reply
1102 sats \ 1 reply \ @ek 22 Jul
I can’t imagine not writing cursive
reply
This! Each type of writing is different.
If I really need to retain something I need to write it by hand.
If I am writing creatively, it is much more natural and flowing if I start in cursive for the first draft.
I am fastest at a keyboard, but the writing has less 'me' in it.
As voice-recognition and ai improve, I like natural language speaking to my devices.
reply
Not knowing it is illiteracy by definition, it's also good practice for dexterity and comprehension
Very likely it'll class stratify in time, already is
Also if skynet becomes reality it's how underground clans will encode their letters to one another
reply
This just got me to thinking we need an airline only for people that can write in cursive
reply
or social media
reply
Stylus based proof of work authentication, would take much more compute to bots to scrape or post... might be onto something.
reply
Call me old school or just fucking old, but how the hell are you an 'educated' person in the U.S.A. if you can't read the Constitution and Bill of Rights in the original hand?!!!
reply
They had some kind of cursive. Never got my own hand looking like that (although, it's not bad).
reply
They were calligraphers!
reply
I have my doubts about the subject, really in current times we write more on the computer or cell phone, than we write by hand... but the art of writing cursive really is beautiful, unfortunately personally I am terrible at writing, my handwriting is horrible.
In fact, with 32 years of having one of my signatures, it is never the same as the other.
reply
but why spend the time on cursive as opposed to, say, watercolor painting.
reply
Personally, I think that, for example, one can put a little effort into handwriting and improve it; however, not everyone has a vocation for the art of painting with watercolors.
reply
102 sats \ 0 replies \ @orto 22 Jul
Why shouldn't they learn a form of writing when they can learn a lot of superfluous things? So, "YES".
reply
102 sats \ 1 reply \ @grayruby 22 Jul
Our son learned but we haven’t taught our daughter. If she wants to learn then great, if not we can probably skip it.
reply
I think I will continue to teach my kids, but it feels only slightly less useful than alphabetization skills and using an index/dictionary.
reply
114 sats \ 1 reply \ @nichro 22 Jul
Every time I see actual cursive written, I realize I forget that cursive even exists and that I was forced to use it in school from 3rd grade onwards
reply
I assume this is not a great memory...
reply
102 sats \ 1 reply \ @fiatbad 22 Jul
That's like asking "Should kids learn Pig-Latin?"
If your answer is "yes" to both, then at least you're consistent.
But if you think Pig Latin isn't going to offer them much in life, and you think cursive is, then you're just out of touch with our modern reality.
I believe that kids should learn all kinds of stuff. The more the better. Teaching pig-latin and cursive is a good thing, for fun. But NOT if it's taught as a seriously important subject where they're tested and spend days learning it.
Spend a day on it for fun. Make it lighthearted.
reply
As a cursive enjoyoor, I have to admit you have a pretty good point.
reply
kids should learn things that force their minds into adopting a "system of thinking"
learning python forces them to think in logical steps
Learning cursive helps their long term memory learn a skill with a rubric
Memorizing multiplication tables help them develop pattern recognition.
Learning a sport helps them connect mind and body
reply
The private school my kid goes to teaches cursive first. It's actually better in many ways.
reply
Why do you think it's better?
reply
Seems like a waste of time and energy
reply
If you had a choice between teaching your kids cursive and thumb-typing (like all the kids do with their phones) which would you do?
I realized in writing that that nobody really had to teach thumb typing. It just kinda is.
reply
I think teaching how to swipe would be better. I still have people all the time amazed when I swipe 😆
reply
102 sats \ 4 replies \ @OT 22 Jul
Cursive or just writing in general? I think it's worth spending some time making their writing look nicer. Probably not too much as all they'll probably ever need is a keyboard to type with. But even that might be replaced by high quality speech to text software.
reply
I do spend more time with them on a keyboard than on cursive, but that's because we do a lot of school on computers.
reply
That was something I only fixed as an adult — my handwriting used to be really messy, and that was one of the reasons I switched to print. Now I write nicely in both styles.
reply
21 sats \ 1 reply \ @OT 22 Jul
It's probably something I need to work on a bit. Sometimes I need to write in a card and realize that my writing sux.
reply
I still haven’t mastered the art of writing fast and neatly in cursive. To make it look good, I need to take a bit more time.
reply
Is that a problem? Honest question. Here where I live, we’ve learned cursive since childhood.
reply
I'm homeschooling. But my impression is that they do not teach it in public schools here. I may be wrong.
reply
So, I think you should teach. Because it requires more technique, I understand that it's good for children.
reply
Oops, I voted no by mistake.
Cursive handwriting is important. It's now almost a lost art (not lost yet, going to be lost in future generations). There are a few younger folk out there who are discovering and learning it, hopefully they carry it on to their own kids.
reply
In Brazil, we're taught cursive from a young age — it's the standard way we learn to write in school. 😶‍🌫️
reply
I’ve never understood the resistance the cursive. Most people tell me that no one uses cursive anymore so why teach it? But the same could almost be true of printing now that most people have devices.
reply
I read somewhere that cursive helps reduce spelling errors for dyslexics because they don’t lift their fingers off the page.
But I think in reality, I feel that my time with my children is limited, so cursive moves down the priority rungs for me. Particularly so because many people don’t quite know how to read cursive. I don’t want him to be inadvertently disadvantaged because of other people’s ignorance
reply
How about just learn what you enjoy learning about.
reply
why don't let the kids decide?
reply
Helps the brain develop its creative nature!
reply
Does it come with any cognitive benefits? My sister can and she once inspired me to attain it, all in vain. Although let me show you how it looked in 2002
And now
reply